When an entertaining show with fairly decent reviews struggles, what message do you get out of it?
That it's most likely a low priority on the list of things to see for most people. Just like the hundreds of entertaining shows with fairly decent reviews that came before it.
Star driven vehicles seem to make it even if they stink up the place. Legendary new works thrive no matter what the price of tickets may be. Apparently people want to see shows for bragging rights but seem to shy away from ordinary shows that just want to entertain.
When has this ever not been the case? Are you expecting the entire history of musical theatre to completely change for On Your Feet?
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian