I actually think the Carpenters could be a really inspired idea.
The first thought might be they could be a little too old school, that many in the younger generation wouldn't know who they are, or that maybe their music is a little too old-fashioned for some.
But after coming across some reaction videos on YouTube lately and seeing how many of their songs pop up, and are being reviewed by younger men, younger women and younger couples, it is so heartwarming to see the love Karen gets. And it's understandable. She had a beautiful and rich voice that just took you to amazing places though her storytelling in song. One of the best voices we've ever had the honor of experiencing.
Just seeing these younger YouTubers hearing her for the first time, and their jaws just drop as she starts the song and they hear her for that first time. By the end of the piece they're thanking their viewers for recommending the Carpenters and to please suggest more, because they want to hear more of their songs.
One YouTuber even acknowledged that some might see their songs as a little corny (sappy?), I can't remember his words, but he said they really aren't. They are just full of emotion and love. And for some young man in his early 20s to recognize the brilliance of their music is so nice to see. You'll watch young couples listening to them for the first time, the young woman who is listening to her has tears filling her eyes, while he sits there just shaking his head at how great Karen is.
And when you consider Richard's brilliance in arrangement and vocals and harmonies, this is something else these YouTubers call attention to, not knowing that he was responsible for their sound. They'll say things like, 'Wow, the harmonies are amazing,' or 'Listen how great it is when that instrument comes in at that moment.' I know Richard is approaching 80, but bring him in as a consultant and part of the arrangement team.
Bring in their life stories, with her struggles with body image and anorexia, and his struggles with drugs. Their relationship with one another, and with their parents. Their mother's favoritism toward Richard. There are so many dynamics you could bring into this to make it so universal to even younger generations.
You could also have a Herb Alpert character (their ties to A&M records) and even John Lennon who stopped her in a restaurant in LA and said: "I want to tell you love, I think you've got a fabulous voice." She was in such disbelief that she had to confirm with the friend she was with if he had really said that, and if her friend thought John really meant it. Paul McCartney was even on record as saying she had one of the best voices he had ever heard.
I mean, there could be a lot to work with here.
Call it Yesterday Once More. 