First of all, he's very different from Bobby. If you go in expecting a clone of Bobby's (remarkable) performance, you'll be disappointed.
Berry's voice is a lot deeper, but it's gorgeous. The one song I didn't enjoy his voice in was the first I Am the One, where, because its so booming, it sounded like he was singing in a concert and not to Diana.
He makes some interesting acting choices. He doesn't break down like Bobby does, but is rather, more resigned to all of this happening. Almost like, he's been down this road with Diana many times before, and nothing surprises him. At the end of the I Am the One reprise, just as Gabe starts running off, Berry reaches his arm out to try and grab him, to pull him back. Very effective.
Of course, he's not as good as Bobby (who should be Tony winner Bobby Spencer), but he's excellent in his own right. I really, really, enjoyed him and would be happy to see him again.
Updated On: 9/26/09 at 02:12 PM