Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
#1Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 12:29pm
Ever heard a performer singing on a cast recording, then saw what they looked like and were surprised that they didn't look like you imagined? It seems to happen to me all the time.
When I first heard James Barbour singing, I imagined him MUCH older, and bigger, with grey hair, a mustache, and a really pointy nose. I didn't see Michael Ball looking as boyish and... dimply and smiley...as he does. I imagined him with much squarer features and a sterner-looking face, more like Michael Maguire.
I saw Patti LuPone with a rounder face and very, very tightly curly grey hair. In my mind, Susan Egan looked a lot curvier with long curly blonde hair. I always invisioned Idina Menzel as being really small and skinny with chin-length hair.
But the weirdest one? For years and years, I was convinced that Terrence Mann was a really, really, really lanky bald black guy with a feminine-looking face.
#2re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 12:35pm
My former housemate had some very unflattering things to say about Norbert Leo Butz first time she saw a picture of him. She'd grown used to the 'Wicked' cast recording playing through her wall (at appropriate times of day and respectful volumes), and was quite taken with Fiyero's voice. Her response to show photographs was "I thought that was Chistery!!!". -_-;; She couldn't quite... reconcile the voice and the face.
I'm sure I must have some of my own, but I'll have to get back to you. Nothing as outlandish as some of yours, Schmergy! 
#2re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 12:36pmJames Barbour shocked me. I saw him then he sang, I thought he was dubbed.
#3re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 12:44pmDid you imagine him with a mustache, too? I think he has a very mustachey sort of voice.
#4re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 12:49pmI saw him before he sung. I expected him to have a high voice.
#5re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 1:12pm
That's like how when I first saw Tituss Burgess, I thought he'd have a deep voice. Then he started wailing out these ridiculously high notes and I started looking around to make sure that some woman onstage wasn't singing.
I know that when I first saw Michael Crawford, he didn't look like I expected, but I can't remember how I thought he'd look.
eatlasagna
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/6/04
#6re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 1:17pm
Matt Borgart
not a broadway performer... but when she released her first CD years ago, i always thought Pink was a black woman
#7re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 3:48pmThis isn;t broadway, but Kimya Dawson has such a youthful voice, I pictured her as a small young woman. Boy was I wrong
#8re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 3:52pmMe. 5'9 and have the voice of kristin chenoweth.
xoangel2789xo
Broadway Star Joined: 11/3/07
#9re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 4:16pmI can't think of any performers, but I sound a lot tinier than I am.
bwaylvsong
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/28/05
#10re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 4:24pmAnd I sound a lot bigger than I am.
#11re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 4:24pmI used to think that Shoshana Bean was a large black woman
candydog2
Featured Actor Joined: 8/11/07
#13re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 4:36pm
I know she's not a broadway performer, but I don't think Amy Winehouse looks anything like her voice.
As for Broadway specifically, I'd have to say Josh Strickland - he sounds a lot like an afro-american contralto woman. It's not a high voice, just a feminine one.
#14re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 5:02pm.....and wilson jermaine heredia! in ill cover you i just pictured him as this tiny tan blonde guy for some reason.
#15re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 6:29pm
Farah Alvin sounds so much more attractive than she is.
And not Broadway...but I was shocked when I found out Sean Paul isn't black.
Parks
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/5/04
#16re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 7:10pmNot Broadway--but Nikka Costa takes the cake in this department.
#17re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 7:13pm
The first one that comes to mind is Eden Espinosa.
She's this tiny little thing, and then this immense, incredibly powerful voice comes out of her!
I can't believe she has that inside her little body.
-Kad
"I have also met him in person, and I find him to be quite funny actually. Arrogant and often misinformed, but still funny."
-bjh2114 (on Michael Riedel)
#18re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 7:16pm
Tobias-- Yeah! There's something frail about Idina Menzel's voice, for some reason. I always saw her as this tiny, skinny little birdlike thing.
Also, when I first heard Rob Evan, I imagined him to be skinny with really big circles under his eyes and extremely curly hair. I don't know why.
Sondheim_Geek
Broadway Star Joined: 2/20/07
#19re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/21/08 at 7:44pm
Josh Young
J. Robert Spencer
Carolee Carmello (her vibrato)
geekgirl06
Featured Actor Joined: 11/9/06
#20re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/22/08 at 3:39am
Susan Egan, definitely
And then there's always Rick Astley :)
DefyGravity777
Broadway Legend Joined: 1/28/08
#21re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/22/08 at 4:05amJulie Reiber. This first time I heard her sing I thought she was still in her teens and that was last year...LOL. Onstage as Elphaba she is so angry then when she sings out comes this high pitched girly voice.
#22re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/22/08 at 4:14pmHahahah, YES. Rick Astley. Did anyone NOT think he was black?
#23re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/22/08 at 4:15pm
Sondheim_Geek, agreed about Josh Young. And also I can't believe you actually know who he is haha.
I'd also have to say Norbert Leo Butz. He sounds wayyy prettier than he looks. It's a shame.
#24re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/22/08 at 5:08pm
Rosalind Russell sounds a lot like Lisa Kirk... ;^) - pace Roz, I love ya.
For real, I guess I'd say Mandy Patinkin. It doesn't matter what recording it is, I'm always surprised at that high clear head voice.
And I guess Harvey Fierstein for the first time...
NicoletteSisk
Swing Joined: 9/30/08
#25re: Performers Who Don't Look Like Their Voices
Posted: 9/30/08 at 2:30am
Farah Alvin looks just like she sounds, at least to me. Completely gorgeous!
Also, I agree with the Shoshana comment. I thought the SAME thing about her being a big black lady!
Videos