I play the overture every July 4th, and tear up. It's a beauty. I saw the OBC in a preview and the Papermill iteration, which didn't so much improve the show as simply change it. The score is exhilarating, but like "Merrily" and "Candide," it has a disconnect between the ambitions of the book and the execution. It's just about too many people and many get lost in act one. It also has a leading man who -- when he finally appears -- doesn't bring much of interest to the story. I dearly love every note of the score, but the storytelling is just too diffused.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling