Shoshana's songs are way more catchy. I have Idina's album and honestly, I like only 2 songs and even so, they sound pretty similar. I still firmly believe Idina should do more jazz, rather than pop.
And just that day I was randomly checking out Sho's singles off her myspace and my housemate passed by and he was like, "Woah, who's that? It's awesome." Well perhaps, with more airtime on the radio, ppl will start noticing her singles first before they know who Shoshana is, because granted she isnt very popular. Her first single is critical.
With idina's case, it was more like "Oh, Star of smash hit RENT and WICKED - here's her CD." But her pop songs pale in comparison to what the pop industry can offer. Plus, she isnt that popular out of MT circles either.
Maybe that could make all the difference? Just hope it works out for her too, she deserves it.
In Soviet Russia, Wicked hates you too!