I was there when Gideon Glick was out (the 18th of this month). Robert Hager did a fine job in every way and has a really sweet voice, but looks a little too young and innocent for me to be comfortable during "The Word of Your Body (Reprise)". Hanschen just seemed far too lecherous.
Then again, that's the only time I saw the show, so I don't know how the scene plays with Glick.
Honestly, I think all the secondary characters could have used more attention. I hated Melchior and Wendla.
broadwayunderstudies.com - most underrated performers on broadway