Producer2 said: "Sorry Patti!"
What does this even mean?
I don't think many of us expected these controversies to appreciably affect the box office. That doesn't mean the underlying issues aren't worth discussing.
Controversy notwithstanding, do we think they’ll even attempt to keep this show running after Nicole? Or will they just call it a day?
Leading Actor Joined: 3/8/22
CreatureKitchen said: "Controversy notwithstanding, do we think they’ll even attempt to keep this show running after Nicole? Or will they just call it a day?"
It was rumored they would take the production to LA in November of 2025; I would assume they close in July and Nicole takes a long vacation before the LA run. If what I read is even true/plans don't change. I can also imagine a scenario where they try to find another name to replace Nicole and keep running in New York.
Maybe this is more to do with Patti’s troubled history with the show? The OP thinks the success of this production somehow irritates her? I have no idea.
#MakeNormaGreatAgain
Chorus Member Joined: 3/3/23
CreatureKitchen said: "Controversy notwithstanding, do we think they’ll even attempt to keep this show running after Nicole? Or will they just call it a day?"
I remember a rumor that Heather Headley was a potential replacement.
I wonder if they will stay in the same vein and cast someone like Christina Aguilera.
Wow, I'd never have thought but Christina Aguilera could be perfect - she is a name, has an incredible, incredible voice and definitely fits with faded pop star vibe concept of production. I would 100% go back. Can she act though? I guess she tried and Jamie Lloyd has a heavy hand.
With the Russel Brand controversy; I would LOVE to see Katy Perry as Norma.
I heard they want to open an LA production with Anne Hathaway as Norma?
Anybody but that miscast Trump princess!
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/28/05
Impeach2017 said: "Anybody but that miscast Trump princess!"
Miscast? She is the reason the production is playing on Broadway. She is perfectly cast for this particular production. Her performance is what is selling tickets. We can be angry or disappointed that her vote didn't align with the values of the theatre community and the funding of the arts, but let's not kid ourselves about the performance she is giving in the production she has been cast in. She would be miscast in Trevor Nunn's production, but this production was built around her as a performer. By nearly all accounts, she is this production of Sunset Blvd., love it or leave it. If she doesn't win the Tony (and at this point I am not convinced she will), it will be because of politics and Tony voters not supporting her as a person, not because they feel she was miscast; that will be something we discuss for decades, as I feel it was pretty much a sure thing until this past week.
Chorus Member Joined: 11/15/12
jimmycurry01 said: "Impeach2017 said: "Anybody but that miscast Trump princess!"
Miscast? She is the reason the production is playing on Broadway. She is perfectly cast for this particular production. Her performance is what is selling tickets. Wecan be angry or disappointed that her vote didn't align with the valuesof the theatre community and the funding of the arts, but let's not kid ourselves about the performance she is giving in the production she has been cast in. She would be miscast in Trevor Nunn's production, but this production was built around her as a performer. By nearly all accounts, she is this production of Sunset Blvd., love it or leave it. Ifshe doesn't win the Tony (and at this point I am not convinced she will), it will be because of politics and Tony voters not supporting her as a person, not because they feel she was miscast; that will be something we discuss for decades, as I feel it was pretty much a sure thing until this past week."
I think you may be slightly skewered in your estimation- many discerning folks have not be impressed with her abilities beyond the pop vocals. Yes, they have tailored this production to her abilities— make fun and parody to conceal what she cannot deliver as an actress. I don’t think she’d be winning a Tony for this either way. In my opinion, it’s an ultimately silly production without impact beyond the awesome sound design and crystalline vocals, and I think Tom Francis comes off best navigating these heavy-handed waters.
Nicole would be miscast in the original production or any production since. But not this production - it would be like saying Alice Ripley is miscast in next to normal. Nicole IS Norma.
Broadway Star Joined: 6/3/18
I loved the idea of Christina Aguilera but I doubt her voice would fit the role - it sounds too “dry” for me. Here’s CA singing recently (2024)
https://youtu.be/plZ2OB4hSsg?si=OIxU015f1FgSELWY
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/23/17
yahyahyah said: "
I think you may be slightly skewered in your estimation- many discerning folks have not be impressed with her abilities beyond the pop vocals. Yes, they have tailored this production to her abilities— make fun and parody to conceal what she cannot deliver as an actress. I don’t think she’d be winning a Tony for this either way. In my opinion, it’s an ultimately silly production without impact beyond the awesome sound design and crystalline vocals,and I think Tom Francis comes off best navigating these heavy-handed waters."
You are insanely delusional.
Chorus Member Joined: 3/3/23
Yeah dream casting replacements for this production is a fun puzzle. Christina is my best choice. Lindsay Lohan doesn't have the voice, Britney doesn't have the acting chops... In the theater realm: Idina Menzel feels ideal on paper (Redwood be damned), Rene Elise Goldsberry more or less played a financially drought norma in Girls5eva, Jane Krakowski, Toni Collette...
It's sad that people are continuing to try to keep this faux controversy going. Maybe the ladies from The View can explain it better: The View on X: "NICOLE SCHERZINGER BEING UNFAIRLY MALIGNED? After the singer apologized for commenting that she wanted a MAGA-esque “Make Jesus First Again” hat on social media, #TheView co-hosts weigh in. https://t.co/j7aqmIPxh2" / X
Videos