I have all the 3 English cast recordings of the show and each of them has qualities that the others don't:
LONDON ORIGINAL: best singing, especially "With One Look" - it's in the original key, the tempo doesn't 'go back and forth'. Sadly, a lot of the dialogue was cut from this one.
AMERICAN PREMIERE: best covering of the show, has practically the whole show recorded. Sure, Close's not the best singer, emotionally she's the strongest.
CANADIAN RECORDING: best orchestra sound. It's the biggest (to my knowledge) of these Sunset Orchestras with 56-piece orchestra (23 theatre musicians and 33 additionals) playing the score.
Each has its pros and cons but I think each one is worth buying.
Updated On: 5/16/07 at 08:40 AM