Holdren in Vulture is positive
The Curious Paradox of the Rethought Fantasticks
The show's inherent sweetness makes it to Broadway intact--and gender-flipping it into a gay love story turns out to require barely any changes.
https://www.vulture.com/article/theater-review-the-fantasticks-finally-on-broadway.html
"As Bessie Mae Bellomy, mother to Lewis, and Mildred Hucklebee, mother to Matt, Ruthie Ann Miles and Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer are at least 65 percent of what makes this revival as lovely as it is. (A significant chunk of the rest goes to David Patrick Kelly and Kevin Del Aguila, masterful in their buffoonery as a pair of dauntless, dusty old actors — but more on them soon.) Kritzer and Miles have just as much chemistry as their boys, perhaps even more, and they deploy it meticulously and brilliantly. Their renditions of “Never Say No” and “Plant a Radish,” the musical’s two very funny songs about the impenetrable mysteries of parenting, are like getting to witness a dream version of MCC’s annual Miscast gala. With the latter of the two songs, the production’s team goes even further, achieving a gentle little revelation by slowing down the beginning and letting Miles — so gifted with both comedy and pathos — start out mournfully, only warming up over time to the song’s eventual bounce and swagger.
This is the kind of adjustment that adds more truly unique flavor to this Fantasticks than the Luisa-Lewis switch. When it comes to that switch, it’s actually everything about the show that has remained the same that gives us opportunities to****our heads and rethink. Matt, as the slightly older of the boys — the one who’s comically convinced that he’s “grown-up, stable, willing to conform” — has always dreamed of doing the saving while Luisa, now Lewis, dreams of being saved. Keep the show hetero and such a construction is going to start to grate. Now, there’s something freeing in watching a young man dream of getting “kissed upon the eyes” and carried off by “a braggadocio bandit.” The regendering allows for a little breath, a little relaxation, perhaps even a drop of radical honesty: I mean, who doesn’t want to get carried off by a hot bandit sometimes?"