Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
#7

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

We already have a thread devoted to this production. Now it will disappear into the darkness because OP per usual has started another thread while talking to him or herself.

Updated On: 11/16/26 at 06:21 AM

#10

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

When I saw it, he was wearing some truly hideous gaucho pants. Maybe those tight little things ripped? 🤣



(I had a lovely time at this charming revival, by the way)

#12

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

Vincentelli in NYT is not a Critic's Pick. More positive on act one than two.

‘The Fantasticks’ Review: A Gender Swap for a Still-Tender Story

Now two men play the young lovers in this long-running musical from 1960. Its quaint nostalgia remains intact for this Broadway production.

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/16/theater/the-fantasticks-review-broadway.html

"We kick back into action with the swinging “This Plum Is Too Ripe,” but the production then starts spinning its wheels. Partly this is a factory setting, as Jones’s book summons disputes and dramatic declarations out of thin air to kick-start his point about the disappointments brought on when romantic fantasy runs into reality. The grandness does not sound as natural anymore. “I’ll drink and gamble!” Matt says, announcing he’s taking off on an adventure. “I’ll grow a mustache!”

Lewis matches him: “I’ll have an affair!” he retorts.

Gattelli, so at ease earlier, does not have a solution for the tonal changes. Or maybe he does not want to fully engage with them and what they might look like, especially when Lewis and El Gallo grow close.

He is also hampered by the fact that El Gallo slips out of Phillips’s grasp as the show goes on and the character moves from Cupid’s little helper to manipulative schemer. The actor’s muscular physique — he looks ready to star as Jack Reacher’s long-lost brother — is made even more distracting by a carnival-strongman costume that is the designer Linda Cho’s single faux pas. El Gallo needs to act a little bit dashing but also a little bit dastardly; Philipps (who does acquit himself well in the musical numbers) does not quite fulfill either."

#13

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

NY Stage Review

The Fantasticks: Fresh but Still Familiar

By Melissa Rose Bernardo

★★★★☆ The longest-running musical in history makes its Broadway debut with a new boy-meets-boy story



The Fantasticks: Somehow Short of Fantastic(k)

By David Finkle

★★★☆☆ The Tom Jones-Harvey Schmidt off-Broadway classic in a Broadway revisal, Christopher Gattelli directs, choreographs

#14

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

Deadline

‘The Fantasticks’ Review: A Welcome Broadway Debut Seven Decades In The Making

https://deadline.com/2026/11/the-fantasticks-broadway-review-1237223063/

"Gattelli and his fine cast of newcomers and veterans know perfectly well what they’re up to – and up against, staying faithful to the winsomeness that kept The Fantasticks running Off Broadway for a total 42 years (!). They know that abandoning the ingratiating amiability and theater-kid appeal of this Tom Jones-Harvey Schmidt musical that gave early breaks to Jerry Orbach and many generations of soon-to-be stars would be like cutting “Try To Remember” from the score.

No small part of this revival’s pleasures are the coming together of relative newcomers – Maxim Chlumecky and Nathan Levy as the two boys, Fire Island‘s Zane Phillips making an impressive Broadway debut as El Gallo – with beloved stage figures Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles (as the mothers). They’re all terrific singers with crowd-pleasing comic skills – Kritzer and Miles perform a splendid song-and-dance number, “Never Say No,” early in the show – and their matched by a supporting cast that includes David Patrick Kelly, Kevin del Aguila and Ahmad Simmons."

#15

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

Theatermania

Review: The Fantasticks Is a Gay Old Time on Broadway—but Not Gay Enough

Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt’s long-running musical returns to New York City.

https://www.theatermania.com/news/review-the-fantasticks-is-a-gay-old-time-on-broadway-but-not-gay-enough_1859835/



"Chlumecky and Levy are an endearing pair, filling their roles with a naivete that communicates the thrill of first love—and their duets on classic songs “Metaphor,” “Soon It’s Gonna Rain,” and “They Were You” are divine. Chlumecky is a genuine star with charisma to spare, and he’s an especially gifted physical comedian, too—his limp-wristed sword fight with the bandits is a guffaw-inducing highlight.

Levy palpably conveys the carnality that romance eventually brings about, but he’s let down by Jones’s revisions, which change the character’s name and pronouns without meaningfully considering how a young gay man might act in these situations. A more contemporary set of eyes might have gone further and deeper, but what Levy is given is just Louisa by any other name. His Lewis is filled with youthful élan, and it’s not his fault that the material doesn’t live up to it."

#17

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

WSJ:

‘The Fantasticks’ Review: Boy Meets Boy on Broadway

The long-running, widely produced musical finally comes to the Great White Way in a production, directed by Christopher Gattelli, that gives its whimsical love story a twist.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-fantasticks-review-boy-meets-boy-on-broadway-68553e05

"A “Fantasticks” virgin no more, I cannot say I lament missing the original, both because the new version, as noted, doesn’t make major departures from the prior one—it’s a meticulously mounted replica, on a modestly larger scale, of the minimalist, story-theater-style original—and because the whimsy factor, while not as nerve-grating as I feared, still has little appeal. That said, the production, directed and choreographed with palpable affection by Christopher Gattelli (“Schmigadoon!”), boasts a wonderful cast that does fine justice to the undeniably lovely score. (One welcome change: simple but richer orchestrations by Sam Davis.)"

#18

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

The Wrap: The typically negative Hofler is positive

‘The Fantasticks’ Broadway Review: The Vintage Musical Successfully Moves Uptown Under a Lavender Moon

https://www.thewrap.com/creative-content/theater/the-fantasticks-broadway-review-the-vintage-musical-successfully-moves-uptown-under-a-lavender-moon/

"Curiously, the gayest thing about this “Fantasticks” is not that two boys consummate their love singing “Soon It’s Gonna Rain.” No, it’s The Narrator, a.k.a. El Gallo, who, in the person of Zane Phillips, is as close to a Tom of Finland illustration as I’ve ever seen come to life on stage. The word “buff” doesn’t begin to describe his arms, which appear ready to explode if anyone goes sharp on a high note.

Chlumecky and Levy are adorable together, but the real sexual heat is between each of them and Phillips.

If there’s anything that connects Gattelli’s work on “Fantasticks” to his previous Broadway musicals, “Schmigadoon!” and “Death Becomes Here,” it’s the absurdly comic performances that often lights up his shows. It’s not always clear what The Old Actor and his sidekick The Man Who Dies are doing in this show, but whenever David Patrick Kelly and Kevin Del Aguila are on stage, it is an utter delight."

#19

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

USA Today

'The Fantasticks' is the most heart-tugging show on Broadway – Review

Dazzling and dreamy, the first-ever Broadway production of "The Fantasticks" is a wonder to behold.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/music/2026/11/16/fantasticks-review-broadway-musicals/92811425007/



"Every so often, there’s a musical that reminds you just how heavenly a night of theater can be.

Sure, that may sound like an awfully grandiose way to describe something as well-trodden as “The Fantasticks,” which has been kicking around every high school and community playhouse for decades. But at a moment when so many Broadway shows are crutched by insipid star casting and overblown vocal gymnastics, Christopher Gattelli’s sublime and heart-tugging revival feels like an antidote to an industry that’s increasingly allergic to simple, earnest storytelling."

#20

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

Slant

‘The Fantasticks’ Review: A Gay Reimagining Makes the Classic Musical Tenderly Transcendent

Queerness gives the long-running musical’s central romance a tender new sense of wonder.

https://www.slantmagazine.com/theater/the-fantasticks-review-broadway-musical/

"Chlumecky makes Matt a sweet nerd, entirely convincing in his bold, unfancy declarations of love. But it’s Levy who walks away with the show, animating this quixotically innocent gay boy’s oddball imagination. If you miss the musical variety of Luisa’s coloratura soprano, it’s a worthy trade-off for this Lewis’s eccentric effervescence. (Lewis’s existence also happens to save the show from the dated sexism of Luisa’s damsel-in-distress fantasies.)"

#21

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

TimeOut

Broadway review: The Fantasticks (★★★★) makes new magick

Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt's once-musty musical gets refreshed with a blast of young same-sex romance.

https://www.timeout.com/newyork/news/broadway-review-the-fantasticks-makes-new-magick-111726

"The charming new Broadway incarnation of The Fantasticks, lovingly directed and choreographed by Christopher Gattelli, has roots in the show’s storied past; Jason Sherwood’s set begins with a ghost-lit evocation of the original Off Broadway run. But it plants itself firmly in the present, and comes to unexpected bloom. “I thought I had planted a turnip or at worst perhaps an avocado: something remotely useful,” says one of the musical’s parents, using a gardening metaphor to describe her rather exotic child. “What need do I have for a rose?” But we all could use a rose right now. The Fantasticks is a bouquet. "

#22

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

Chicago Tribune

Review: With simple gender switch, ‘The Fantasticks’ gets a new life on Broadway

https://www.chicagotribune.com/2026/11/16/review-fantasticks-broadway/

"Sitting in the Second Stage’s Hayes Theater, the smallest of the Broadway theaters, I was struck by what seeing this show, which is quite charming, will mean to some older gay men, especially Broadway fans who sat through decades of heterosexual relationships in musicals written and scored by gay men. Sure, that’s changed over the last decade or so, but those are new, pop-driven shows and this lyrical one was born in 1960 (with Jerry Orbach as the narrator El Gallo, no less) and felt retro even when I first saw it as a teenager in the early 1980s. It speaks a different language from, say, “The Prom,” and therein lies the nobility (yes, nobility) of this new production, even though it is a modest affair by today’s Broadway standards.

Apropos of that, it’s probably a high compliment to say that if you liked “The Fantasticks” in its original form, then you will like this one, too. (The reverse might also be true). That’s because the director, Christopher Gattelli, manages to make this switch to two boys and their mothers not only feel like the most natural thing in the world, but that the show originally was penned that way."

#24

THE FANTASTICKS (Hayes) Broadway Reviews

Culture Sauce

‘The Fantasticks’ finds new queer love in an old trunk of musical tricks (Broadway review)

https://culturesauce.com/the-fantasticks-broadway-review/

"Still, you’d have to be a hard-hearted cynic yourself to resist the charms of The Fantasticks. This artfully staged revival conjures a nostalgia for plain storytelling, elegant folk melodies with a hint of classicism, and unembellished romanticism — all in a still somewhat intimate setting. No flying witches or swooping vampires or American patriots on spinning turntables. Sometimes all you need is a bell and a whistle — or, in this case, a piano and a harp — to create musical magic. ★★★★☆"

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $67