Chicago Tribune
Review: With simple gender switch, ‘The Fantasticks’ gets a new life on Broadway
https://www.chicagotribune.com/2026/11/16/review-fantasticks-broadway/
"Sitting in the Second Stage’s Hayes Theater, the smallest of the Broadway theaters, I was struck by what seeing this show, which is quite charming, will mean to some older gay men, especially Broadway fans who sat through decades of heterosexual relationships in musicals written and scored by gay men. Sure, that’s changed over the last decade or so, but those are new, pop-driven shows and this lyrical one was born in 1960 (with Jerry Orbach as the narrator El Gallo, no less) and felt retro even when I first saw it as a teenager in the early 1980s. It speaks a different language from, say, “The Prom,” and therein lies the nobility (yes, nobility) of this new production, even though it is a modest affair by today’s Broadway standards.
Apropos of that, it’s probably a high compliment to say that if you liked “The Fantasticks” in its original form, then you will like this one, too. (The reverse might also be true). That’s because the director, Christopher Gattelli, manages to make this switch to two boys and their mothers not only feel like the most natural thing in the world, but that the show originally was penned that way."