habana, double-check the BOM lottery times. I believe the lottery starts at 5:00 on Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays (those days, curtain is at 7:00, I believe). So that means if you lose the lottery, you'll be heading over to the booth around 5:15, and it shouldn't take you more than five minutes to walk over there. I have the TKTS app and tend to check it every day. It seems to me that lots of good shows are generally available at that time, depending on what you want to see, of course.
I plan on doing the same thing next week when my sister comes to town. We already have tickets for Newsies and Once. We're going to TKTS for the Wednesday matinee (hope to see 4000 Miles, the Best Man, Tribes, or War Horse). We're going to do the BOM lottery at 5:00, and after we lose (I'm a pessimist), we'll head over to the booth to see what else on our list is available.
Also, I've recommended the free TKTS app on several occasions. It's great. And the latest version has added a feature called the Go List. You add the shows you want to see to your Go List. Then, just click on the list, and it will show you which of them is available that moment at TKTS.
Also, the booth has a separate line for plays, and it tends to be much shorter than the line for musicals.
Please be sure to double-check the lottery times and don't take my word for it! Have fun!
Updated On: 6/17/12 at 11:36 AM