I attended last night with some friends and we thought it was a gorgeous, overwhelming piece. I admit I am biased, being both a huge fan of Taylor Mac and someone who is willing to give my time to long pieces of performance (this does indeed clock in at just over 4 hours).
There was a substantial amount of audience walkouts- I was in the balcony and I would say about 60% of people left. This is not a performance for everybody- there is no plot, no dialogue. It’s 55 songs inspired by queer figures, ranging from literally about them to more abstract musings that aren’t obviously connected. And yes, it is 4 hours straight through- audience members are encouraged to come and go as they please (which is frankly hard to do in that space).
The music is gorgeous and the ensemble is an embarrassment of riches- voices and personalities that soar off the stage. Machine Dazzle’s costumes are a visual feast, as usual.
I wish the show weren’t at BAM or really any traditional proscenium space- it would have benefited from a more flexible setting where the audience could recline or cuddle or dance or simply easily come and go without causing an entire row to stand up. The sound design was also rough- some performers were not intelligible in the balcony.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."