I would like to see links to these "reports" about Shoshana's attitude. I have honestly not come across this. Have you actually seen this, or just going by what some random probably purposely misinformed poster has said?
Furthermore, I am a fan of Shoshana, but that does not mean that I don't appreciate other genres and styles of singing. I too, am a big Lansbury, Peters, and Rebecca Luker fan. I also like Carolee Carmello too - she was incredible in Urinetown. I just happen to appreciate talent and encourge those who have talent to do well and thrive.
Shoshana is a rare talent, with an incredible range, versitility, style, and technique that is not seen or heard amongst younger performers these days. She can sing with power, and ease, and not demonstrate to us in the audience that she is "WORKING" so hard for us. To me, that displays talent, and technique.
Not to bash Idina, but a couple of times when I have seen her, I had been worried whether or not she is going to have the stamina to sing one of her big numbers. An audience member should not have to worry about something like that, but be drawn into a performance, instead.
So, say what you want about Shoshana, she has the goods to be a successful performer. And I personally, would love to see her play Fanny Brice one day. Why not? She certainly can sing the role.
Cheers,
The Balladeer
"Someone tell the story...Someone sing the song...."
