The Elphaba Shuffle — Page 6

Shoshana is the one that hates Broadway.

you honestly dont chuckle when you say "beancurd" out loud. just try it. seriously.

and clumsy, you shouldnt be afriad to express you opinion so dont worry about it. ..butttt had you said that right in the heart of the bashing i might have feared for you haha

"Shoshana is the one that hates Broadway."

amen

even better.

---

MrBundles, you read till your heart's content!

:)

We won't tell.

---

I love JLT. That post made me think about how much I miss her. Her and Idina had better chemistry than her and Kristin.

---

why don't you all of you ridiculous queens get a frickin life and leave people who you don't know ALONE.

You don't have to like Idina and Shoooooyesterday just because they are friends. Idina may not let you sit with them at lunch period, but she will still let you pay 100 bucks to see her in a show.

Shodoesn'tlikeBroadway, well, doesn't like Broadway. She's said it a million times. She's rude to some, if not many of her fans, and this was waaaaaaay before any of us called her out on this board, which we don't even know if she reads, or if she can even read. Just kidding. Breath.

You can be a bean pole, fine, but please, try some other shows and performers on for size. I'm not saying all of you only like Wicked, but there's a big chunk of beanpoles who don't know anything other than Bean'Orama and what color green she puts on every night. Did you ever think you may just like the idea of Beanburrito, and not the actual execution?

In comparison to most Broadway performers, past and present, Beantheredonethat just doesn't hold up! She's a pop performer, with minimal acting talent. And again, her stinky attitude doesn't help matters

I think it's just a combo of her marginal talent and her really really bad attitude that make use dislike her so much.

And of course, we are all entitled to our opinion. But remember, beanpoles, your opinions will always be more respected if you at least look like you tried to spell check your posts.

And seriously. Shoshana Bean is a performer. If she doesn't want people judging her talent then she shouldn't be a performer. That is part of being in the public eye. Sure she deserves privacy, we give her that. We've never discussed her private life in depth, or anything to that extent. She is a celebrity (a minor one but still) and she is in the public eye.

If you don't want people to judge your talent, remove yourself from performing, because this is nothing compared to the music vultures that will circle around her if she wants an R&B career.

Bobby, that was amazing. I couldnt have said any of that better myself. and Beantheredonethat... love it! The greenbean needs to move on so that I can see Wicked again.

Carolee isn't a big name, but in reality, Idina isn't either. Not to 99.9999 percent of America who has no clue who she is.

Carolee is a great talent. We weren't listing names based on boxo power.

And no I don't know Shoshana, but that's my point. She is what she presents to the public. That is the image she will carve for herself. THere are tons of reports about her being as snot, as well as reports of her being nice. She needs to stick to a an image, because that is what she is going to be known for.

Updated On: 9/18/05 at 02:54 PM

Carolee is one of the most respected, nicest, well reviewed stars on Broadway.

If Carolee is a Lobster, Shoshana is imitation krab.

Listen to Carolee's recorded performances, from Intimate Joy and Elegies to Parade and John and Jen. She is a powerhouse with a huge voice, and a wide emotional range.

Most Beanpoles don't like her because they only respond to to a more modern voice, ala American Idol.

Carolee also has a firm dedication to Broadway and the new American musical, something you can't say about Shoshana.

Listen to her "Tom" or her notes at the end of "Anytime" or "I Have Found" and try to tell me that any "middle-aged" performer can do that. Hardly.

Just because I enjoy Shoshana doesn't mean that I only like the contemporary vocalists of Broadway. I'm a fan of Patti, Bernadette, and Angela as well. So don't judge me based on my liking of Miss Bean's talent.

Carolee is not a tremendous vocalist or actor, in my opinion. Me saying that pisses you off the way same I get pissed when you constantly bash a performer I enjoy. It's all a matter of opinion.