The Humorous Thread of Terrible Casting Ideas — Page 2

The Drowsy Chaperone:
Man In Chair: Taye Diggs
Janet Van De Graff: Allison Janney
Robert Martin: David Hyde Pierce
Trix: Christiane Noll
Chaperone: Megan Hilty
George: Titus Burgess
Feldzieg: Joel Grey
Kitty: Krysta Rodriguez
Aldolpho: Gavin Creel
Gangster 1: John Barrowman
Gangster 2: Brent Barret
Underling: Anthony Rapp
Tottendale: Bebe Neuwirth

Oliver!:
Nancy: Wanda Sykes
Fagin: Brian Stokes Mitchell
Oliver: Adam Reigler
Bill Sykes: Cheyenne Jackson
Mr Bumble: John Gallagher Jr.
Widow Corney: Georgia Engel
Mr. Sowerberry: Edward Hibbert
Mrs. Sowerberry: Laura Benanti
Artful Dodger: Wesley Taylor
Mr. Brownlow: Kelsey Grammar

The Addams Family:
Pugsly: Justin B
Gomez: Colm Wilkinson
Morticia: Julie Andrews
Wednesday: Katie Rose Clarke
Grandmama: Liza
Uncle Fester: Paulo Szot
Lucas: Constantine Mauralis
Alice: Sierra Boggess
Mal: Rowan Atkinson
Lurch: Alex Brightman

Guys and Dolls

Sarah - Liza Minelli
Sky - Harvey Fierstein
Nicely Nicely - Anthony Rapp
Adalaide - Audra McDonald
Rusty Charlie - Brian Stokes Mitchell

Billy Elliot - Chaz Bono
Mrs.Wilkinson - Kendra Wilkinson

---

Desiree Armfeldt as Miss Julie

John Wilkes Booth as Othello

Mel Gibson as Shylock

(ok, I'm done now)

Updated On: 10/19/11 at 01:37 PM

Justin Bieber as J. Pierrepont Finch... this BETTER not happen.