Yeah, I'd have to agree with
shesamarshmallow and
LizzieCurry on Miles Aubrey as Bob Gaudio. He was quite good, it's just that he doesn't look 22 (and I don't really think any of the other guys who could understudy the role do, either). He was clearly pitching up his voice and cultivating awkward body language and a certain social awkwardness, but it just didn't read as 22 (especially when Chris Jones' Frankie calls him "kid."). In act 2, it worked out much better, especially in "Can't Take My Eyes Off You," when he had some great expressions as he was watching Frankie's big moment. His voice is heavier than Erich Bergen's, which was fine, it just was a different sound.
As to Erik Bates, I thought he came off more like a regular guy who happens to be a bit of a loser, rather than Deven May's flamboyant, nearly mythic loser-ness in the role. He was more subdued, in accent and in general presentation; it just was an interpretation that was quieter.
They both were really good, though, especially considering it has to be pretty terrifying to go on for the first time. I'd be curious to see either or both of them when they've had a few more performances under their belts.
'"Contrairiwise," continued Tweedledee, "if it was so, it might be; and if it were so, it would be; but as it isn't, it ain't. That's logic."'
~Lewis Carroll
Updated On: 4/23/07 at 10:12 PM