Was Black Watch better than August? Having seen both, I'd say yes. As far as it's possible to compare two such very different works.
Black Watch was a triumph of theatre, encompassing acting, movement, sound, and delivering an absolutely devastating truth to stunned audiences.
August: Osage County was frickin' awesome, and also did its part to deliver devastating truths, but while it would probably deservedly come top any other year, it's impossible for anything to compete with the near-perfection delivered by
Black Watch. :3
August: Osage County came from America, did well at the Tonys, didn't do so well at the Oliviers.
Sunday in the Park with George (revival) came from the UK, did well at the Oliviers, didn't do so well at the Tonys. These things balance out. Plus I'm sure they must've taken into consideration that
August: Osage County didn't originate in the UK and was transported in its entirety from the US; it was frickin' awesome, but hardly a triumph of British theatre. So while it was frickin' awesome, I'm not exactly hugely sad it's not getting anywhere tonight.