There was one time in January 2004 when I was going to take a group of my high school students to see Phantom on a Friday night, but the Wednesday before we had a snow day, so I went and saw the matinee. Seeing it that close together was a bit much even for me. When the sound was replaced in August 2008, I bought tickets to the last show before the sound shutdown, and the first show after the shutdown, so I could really compare the difference. Well, I went to the show before the shutdown, but 4 days later, I just gave the tickets away because I didn't feel like going again so soon.
The first time I saw Phantom on Broadway was Wednesday, December 16, 1998. I had seen the touring version twice before.
Some of the funniest experiences seeing Phantom were:
-having one of my high school students say "the director of this show really knows what he's doing! As soon as everybody in the audience falls asleep, he makes sure to have an actor scream or something crash so everybody wakes up!" Shady, lol.
-During Don Juan, Carlotta used to hold an apple and then she would stick it in the dead pig's mouth as it was carried past her. At least five times I saw her stick the apple in the pig's mouth only to have it pop back out. It was interesting to see when an actor would finally pick it up.
-During Carlott's Think of Me, the crew dropped the curtain one chorus too early. So the actors were all in the way and some got it. And the company had to basically ignore it. Then, when it came time for the actual cue, and the lighting and the music changed, and now everybody is screaming.........it was messy. But funny.
-I always feel bad for the Phantom who cannot hold out the final "night" in Music of the Night. Happens quite often.
-Once when a friend and I sat front row center, we stood up at intermission and had the people behind us take our picture with the chandelier resting on the stage. As we prepared for the picture, the chandelier started its ascent and we have one picture with the chandelier right behind our heads and another picture of us ducking out of the way. I know it couldn't have hit it us but man was it close.
-I looooooove the scene with the actor in the pit and when his gun goes off. Everybody in the audience jumps and laughs nervously. I love seeing people have so much fun. And when the Phantom says "I'm here" through different speakers in the house, everybody keeps darting their head around to look---tons of fun.
-For several years during Il Muto, the actor playing the husband would hold out the word "her" on the line "I will hide over there to observe herrrrrrrrr". Audiences didn't know whether to laugh or clap or what. Luckily they stopped that bit.
-once I sat next to a couple who was making out rather passionately during All I Ask of You. At intermission, they asked me how I liked the show, and I told them that they were distracting me and occasionally elbowing me. They got up and did not come back for Act 2.
-My saddest Phantom memory was the two Saturdays after 9/11 when the news was reporting that all the long running shows would have to close because there would not be any tourism in New York for quite some time. So I went to see Phantom one last time. I bought a rear mezz seat. Before the show started, they moved everyone out of the rear mezz, front mezz, and orch into the first 5 rows of the orchestra. The rest of the theater was completely empty. It broke my heart and I thought that there was no way the show could possibly last even one more week like this.