"I'm sorry, I didn't see that show, what is the seemingly anti-semitic reference???
THAT is your favorite 3 seconds?
How sad that is...
Please, enlighten me...I don't get it!"
This is the moment when Caroline has had enough. Noah made her give back the $20 she found in her pocket and at this point in her life she can't take any more. He tells her:
"There's a bomb!
President Johnson has built a bomb
Special-made to kill all Negroes
I hate you
I hate you
Kill all Negroes
Really for true!
I hope he drops his bomb on you!"
Just this alone stuns Caroline and she responds to this immature and childish and hateful statement with the most hateful thing she can tell this small Jewish boy.
"And hell's where Jews go when they die"
That moment when she says this to the one person in the show who honestly admires her is simply amazing, sad and powerful. She is taking all of her frustration out in one sentence on a little boy. She has used her Christianity as a means of killing him. This is the moment that sets her upon her quest for true change. Caroline isn't necessarily Anti-Semitic but she is subject to the same prejudices as whites were to blacks in the 1960's.
When Caroline utters those hurtful words (to paraphrase the show) 'our hearts bleed for her' and she instantly withers inside. She is ashamed of herself but more than just shame, she wants to kill the Caroline who would say that, the Caroline who when she speaks "all that comes out is hate!" She needs to kill that Caroline and create and change and become a Caroline that can live and work and provide for her children. Do not take this as a moment where Anti-Semitism is celebrated. It couldn't be further from the truth. That moment is when the worlds of Caroline and Noah collide and implode.
I highly reccomend the show to anyone of any religion, race, creed, etc. It is stirringly powerful and honest and truthful. It doesn't focus on world events or enormous world-changing moments, it focuses on one woman's desire to change her life and to renew her soul and her spirit in order to love. It is a gorgeous score and a gorgeous show with a message that transcends oppression, racism and all other forms of persecution.
Caroline is Beauty.
BSoBW2: I punched Sondheim in the face after I saw Wicked and said, "Why couldn't you write like that!?"
Updated On: 7/20/05 at 06:48 PM