WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!! — Page 2

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#26

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:07pm

JERSEY BOYS!!???!!!???!!!

Are they on crack? Are they deaf? I mean the pickings for best musical weren't as good as they have been before (still some good shows) but did they have to choose that one?

"He who falls in love with himself will have no rivals" -Benjamin Franklin

#27

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:07pm

"WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATTTT?!?"
^^That was me when they named "The Pajama Game" as winner. Seriously, WTF? That piece of suger-coated fluff wins against a revoluntionary piece of art? I'm going to cry...

#28

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:07pm

And the reason why Sweeney didn't win is beyond me and most of America. I think God is even scratching his head.

And I also thought Patti would win, but she didn't. However, Lachanze deserved it!

BUT I AM BUGGERED!!!!

#29

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:08pm

sorry, double post.

Updated On: 6/11/06 at 11:08 PM

#30

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:11pm

oops

Updated On: 6/11/06 at 11:11 PM

#31

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:14pm

And the secret is out...

...the Tonys are political.

I probably noticed when the nominations came out but there was a lot of "British invasion" with actors with shows like HISTORY BOYS, FAITH HEALRE, and AWAKE AND SING. These 'imports' are showing what is lacking in New York theatre today...in fact, perhaps most of Western Theatre.

I, myself, was surprised by the loss of Best Musical revival to PAJAMA GAME. Personally, I can't understand how such fluff can win over such deep genious of Stephen Sondheim, but that's revivals for ya! Perhaps voters admired the SWEENEY revival, but maybe the minimalist production did not win everyone's favor. I personally prefer the original Prince production (and yes, orchestrations!).

Perhaps a bigger political statement was made with JERSEY BOYS winning best musical. Now, I haven't seen it so I can't even give an opinion as to whether I thought it deserved it. But still, CHAPERONE was a very likely contender. I know it's been discussed but I guess this is the show that joins the "Musicals that won Best Score/Book and lost Best Musical". This is very rare, as we all know. JERSEY BOYS, a purely American (and relatively local story to New York) defends the AMERICAN MUSICAL. CHAPERONE, a Canadian musical, may be considered a Broadway wannabe.

This all makes sense to me at least...If not, I shall shut up.

#32

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:14pm

You know...The Color Purple was an American musical...WHY THE HELL COULDNT THEY GIVE IT TO THEM!!!

Oh and, I can't really stand Sweeney Todd, and even I thought it deserved to win.

#33

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:16pm

How many Tony voters are there? I've read who the nominators are, but not the actual voters.

#34

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:17pm

I just lost so many bets because of Sweeney...

..damn them Tony voters!

#35

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:17pm

"You know...The Color Purple was an American musical...WHY THE HELL COULDNT THEY GIVE IT TO THEM!!!"

No offense to anything regarding the show (this is not me being cynical), but most New York audiences don't care for stories in South. Just like how most of middle America (and yes, the South) don't care for New York theatre. See, it's full circle!

#36

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:17pm

Patti Lupone? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

And how many Tonys did THE WEDDING SINGER win? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

#37

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:21pm

While I agree with most of the winners, there were a few I was confused by.

BEST MUSICAL went to Jersey Boys while it should have gone to The Color Purple or The Drowsy Chaperone

BEST FEATURED ACTRESS in a Musical went to Beth Leavel while it should have gone to Felicia P. Fields

BEST REVIVAL OF A MUSICAL went to The Pajama Game when it should have gone to Sweeney Todd

BEST SCORE/LYRICS went to The Drowsy Chaperone when it should have gone to The Color Purple

BEST SET DESIGN of a Musical went to The Drowsy Chaperone when it should have gone to The Color Purple

BEST FEATURED ACTOR in a Musical went to Christian Hoff (who, don't get me wrong, I thought was great and I'm fine with him winning) but Manoel Felciano deserved it much more

BEST FEATURED ACTRESS in a Play went to Frances de la Tour and it should have gone to Tyne Daly

#38

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:23pm

"No offense to anything regarding the show (this is not me being cynical), but most New York audiences don't care for stories in South. Just like how most of middle America (and yes, the South) don't care for New York theatre. See, it's full circle!"

You know, I live in the South, and that is partialy true. Most people down here dont like New York Theater...but every night RENT came down to B'ham Alabama (yes, I live in the hell thats Alabama) it was sold out. Same with Lion King, 42nd Street, and Hairspray.

So maybe you damn yankees are more discriminatory than us good old Southern boys. Nevermind, forgot that whole period between 1800 since well, hell were still discriminating everyone but rich white christians.

#39

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:23pm

WHAT???? JERSEY BOYS OVER DROWSY CHAPERONE????

Jersey boys isn't even a real SHOW!!!!! It's a freaking JUKEBOX MUSICAL!!!!

*Heart breaks into a million pieces and is stamped on by John Lloyd Young*

Actually, you can't really hate John Lloyd Young.....which makes it even WORSE!!!!!!!!

I put a monkey on a pedestal...

#40

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:25pm

Hi everyone, I'm new, but OMG I CAN'T BELIEVE THE OUTCOME OF THE AWARDS TONIGHT! I feel just like I did when Bernadette Peters was passed over. She deserved that Tony for Gypsy! Sorry....old wounds. Anyway, I think what happened was the vote was split and The Pajama Game just sort of slipped in. I mean, I love the show, but I think Sweeney or Threepenny both deserved it more. Heck, I would have been happy with Threepenny simply because Alan Cumming was involved, but I really am disapointed. Oh well, at least I got to see Stephen Lynch perform so it's not all bad.

#41

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:26pm

Well, this has been interesting.

I'm certainly upset with a lot of the awards (Particularly Jersey Boys' win, because now Drowsy is gonna have a hell of a time attracting audiences with a title like that.)

I'm also upset about The Pajama Game's win, but I find it very interesting. Had Marshall lost, it would have been a repeat of her bout with "Wonderful Town", a well-reviewed show with strong star turns, and nothing but choreography to take home in the face of a Sondheim show. Perhaps the Tony voters were trying to prevent this from happening again? I don't agree with this, I think that Sweeney is the most brilliant show I've ever seen, but it seems the most logical explanation.

#42

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:29pm

Jersey Boys is a real show. Every show on Broadway is a REAL show.

I like to think of Best Book as a consolation prize to the loser of Best Musical. Honestly, I thought Drowsy would win, and I'd have been alright with that - it isn't my favorite, but I understand.

This show turned out a lot different than expected.

#43

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:30pm

Same thread every year...

The wins of Jersey Boys and Pajama Game are par for the course for the Tonys. Why does this surprise people? And as for artistic merit, please try to remember that musical theatre was born out of popular entertainment and ran for decades before artistic merit was a consideration. And it is quite obvious from the ticket-buying public that popular entertainment is still the backbone of commercially successful musicals. Sweeney earned its place in history in its original (and in my opinion, superior) run. A highly stylized minimal prodction does not automatically mean it is good, or that it will appeal to the masses, or the voters. It will appeal to devoted Sondheim fans and fans of unconventional theatre. And these are not the majority. Both revivals got good reviews. It could have gone either way. But the voters may be thinking about a tour, which is the WRONG reason to vote for any show. Or they may have found Pajama Game more entertaining. It happened to Millie/Urinetown and it may have happened here. Who knows? Personally, my vote would have been Urinetown/Pajama Game.

And I don't think The Color Purple had a strong enough book or score to win. Neither did the majority of the reviews, so that was not a surprise at all. But I'm thrilled LaChanze won.

"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian

#44

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:31pm

Actually, you can't really hate John Lloyd Young.....which makes it even WORSE!!!!!!!!

I agree with that completely. He seems like a totally nice (and adorable) guy.

#45

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:36pm

ok lets see the only awards i'm happy with tonite....

John Lloyd Young: TOTALLY DESERVED IT.
Christian Hoff: yes i was cheering for Manoel.... but this came out of nowhere.
Jersey Boys: i wanted Color Purple to win. though Drowsy was def. going to get it. but happy Jersey Boys won.

WHY THE HELL DID PAJAMA GAME GET BEST REVIVAL?!?!?!?
i swear the voters are seriously on something. Harry Connick wasn't even that great it the show. why the hell would they give it best revival? UGH! Sweeney got screwed like non other tonite.

"You can't stop someone who wants to be an artist. If they're going to do it, they're going to do it... Work as hard as you can on the things you can work on. Until it seems like there is no possible chance you're going to succeed, don't give up." ~ANDREW ASNES avatar: me and jason gillman... in the pouring rain.

#46

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:37pm

Honestly, i think that Sweeney has a very selective taste. and not as many people will sit through and enjoy Sweeney as much as Pajama Game. Not that im saying either did or did not deserve anything, im just saying, Sweeney has a very dark and almost depressing tone, as opposed to the light-heartedness of the Pajama Game.

Plus Mrs. O'Hara is gorgeous. and pretty damn talented.

AND regardless if it is a JUKEBOX musical or not, JERSEY BOYS is still amazing, and definetly deserved a tony for best musical.

'Acting provides the fulfillment of never being fulfilled. You're never as good as you'd like to be. So there's always something to hope for.' -- Washington Irving

Updated On: 6/11/06 at 11:37 PM

#47

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:38pm

i agree with you there. my aunt wasn't a fan of Sweeny but i enjoyed it. and yes miss. ohara is amazing.

#48

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:39pm

I couldn't agree more!!!! I saw the show last Sunday and thought there was no doubt that it's brilliance would be awarded tonight. "The Pajama Game"???? I'm sure it's real pretty and fun and about as deep as a west Texas puddle. Sweeney was THEATRE.

#49

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:44pm

lol, Oprah must be so pissed, especially considering that her entire show tomorrow is devoted to the Tonys. Ha. Her musical got virtually nothing.

Everyone else has voiced my opinions on Pajama Game winning. Like, what? Sweeney is clearly superior! That kind of risky and raw direction is so rare and was passed over. I hope it doesn't discourage future directors from pushing the envelope.

#50

re: WHO ARE THESE TONY VOTERS!!!!!!!!!

Posted: 6/11/06 at 11:44pm

We should both collectively get a life, but I've been crying for the past hour. I'm not believing this.

← Back to Message Board

View all Videos

Tickets From $59

Tickets From $71

Tickets From $95