I'm most excited for She Loves Me but I already have tickets. After reading Sara Bareilles' book, I'm hoping Waitress will be great and I think it helps that compared to other shows it's telling a relatively small story. I do want to see Disaster! and Shuffle Along but aside from the casts, there's nothing I'm particularly attached to. Bright Star, Tuck Everlasting, and American Psycho fall into the last group of could be great, mediocre, or terrible. Based on how I'm feeling about Duncan Sheik's work right now, if American Psycho is a big hit I'm just going to assume right now that I won't get it.