Understudy Joined: 7/26/05
Featured Actor Joined: 5/26/04
I dont know since I haven't seen them all, but I like the Broadway one
If Kristin Chenoweth was put into the tour cast instead of Kendra that would be my perfect Wicked cast:)
Understudy Joined: 7/26/05
sorry I posted rather than replied. Several persons who have seen all the productions say current chicago one is the best and that Ana Gasteyer will be going to broadway soon. while the original cd is great, Ana and Kate as well as the entire cast are better. I bet their cd(if they can produce one )will be bigger seller if listners could hear both before buying.
I love the OBC to death, but the newer casts are amazing as well!
The tour :) (says a girl who has seen all three)
the current Bway cast is definetly in last place...sorry but they are
awwwww i loved it when i saw it a few weeks ago on broadway (last time i saw it was original)... i don't think it was that bad! there were a few performances i wasn't impressed with, but i definitely enjoyed it A LOT!
wish i could see some of the others though!
i actually completely disagree with steph the star (sorry, bud)
current bway cast is AMAZING! sho and megan in the same room gives me shudders.
last place is DEFINITELY tour. kendra's a trainwreck and i CAN'T STAND SJ Blo. eck. too shouty. wayyyyy too shouty.
I thought of this after I got offline last night..I should say I've seen the current cast...
when I saw it it was JLT, Saycon, David Ayers, Michelle, Carol Shelley, George Hearn, etc...
that's definitely no longer current! :)
I about cried when I didn't see Sho, that was something I was desperatly looking forward too
But that particular cast that I saw was well under the Tour and Chicago! :) Sorry for my mistake...
Understudy Joined: 4/19/05
Here was my favorite cast: Idina, JLT, Joey McIntyre, Michelle Federer, Christopher Fitzgerald, George Hearn, Carole Shelley, & William Youmans.
Granted I've only seen it on broadway, but I've seen 7 different combinations there. Looking forward to seeing Ana in Chicago soon.
I have seen the original cast in New York and have seen clips of the touring company. Based on what I have seen of the touring company, I like the original cast better. I can make a better comparison in September when I see it here in Denver.
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/31/69
That's a tough question. I don't really like the curreny Broadway cast, but i loved Jennifer and Idina together. Then in the touring cast I like Stephanie and Katie together. I haven't seen the Chicago company yet. I really can't shoose
Broadway Star Joined: 5/9/05
Well I just saw the Chicago cast and I must say they are pretty damn great! The chorus is definatly the best! And if I would have just seen the second act of the Chicago one I would without a doubt vote for Chicago. You have no idea how amazing kate and Ana are in the second act! WOW seriously WOW! The Chicago Nessa is also the best I have heard and seen! She is adorable and has this voice on her!!
I did see some of the current Broadway cast. I was extremely fortunate to catch Idina's "last" performance (basically the red track suite performance) Shoshana and JLT together on stage has been the best theatre I have ever seen in my almost 21 years of life! If you didnt catch them together you have no idea what f***ing amaing theatre is! hehe
I have heard such mixed things about the tour. Most negative about Glinda and Fiyero. I can not make judgments about the tour since I have no seen them. I do enjoy SJB however I must agree with the masses, from what I have heard, she sounds a lot like Lizza and Cher. Amazing talent that girl has though!!!!! I definatly could not endure what she has and even come close to matching her talent!
Swing Joined: 7/14/05
I've only seen the chicago cast because I was too slow to get tickets to the tour and I'm not gettin' to new york anytime soon. I loved the chicago cast with all my heart. I love the OBC recording but (please don't hurt me) I like chicago better. I heard a lot of bad stuff about the tour though. I'm sure they're great but a lot are saying that the chicago and new york casts are better. My poor friend went to see the tour and got understudies for both elphaba and glinda. I hope nobody hunts me down for liking chicago better than OBC...
Broadway Star Joined: 5/9/05
Hey dont you worry Devin! Plenty of people who have seen Chicago cast know exactly what you are talking about! I really wish more people from across the country could really understand how amazing this show is and how amazingly forunate Chicago is to have this more than Broadway quality show here!
BRAVO, MARC!
Elphie love = Dee, Sho, & Steph
Glinda love = Kristin, JLT
Fiyero love = Adam Lambert
Morrible - Carol Shelly. Roni Reed sounds a bit like a drag queen during DG, and Carol Kane is good, but she doesn't sing.
Wizard - David Garrison all the way.
I guess the tour wins, as they have the majority of the love, but I think it'd be kinda fun to try some cast switch ups. Shoshana on tour...whoa baby!
Broadway Star Joined: 9/14/03
shoshana def. grew into the part very well. she is so good in it now
Stand-by Joined: 7/2/05
How do you think the tour cast will be once they get Eden in there??? And how do you think she compares with the other current green girls? (sho, steph, & ana)
I haven't really heard too much about Eden other than a lot of varying opinons on a thread I posted a while ago... but do you think she will strengthen or weaken the tour cast?
And just wondering... I heard one tiny clip of her doing Elphie and I can't say I was too excited... her high belting wasn't all that great... atleast on the cheap (prob illegal) recording... anyone seen her live that can tell me how she really does the belty high stuff??? Hopefully she will do great on the tour!!! (crossing my fingers cuz I alredy have tix!)
Elphaba: Idina -- she gave me goosebumps
Glinda: Toss up between Kristin and JLT
Fiyero: Norbert
Wizard: George Hearn
Madame: Carole Shelley
Boq: Christopher Fitzgerald
Nessarose: Jenna Leigh Green
OBC was definetly the best but Chicago is probably on top right now...
Elphaba - Idina back in the day... or Stephanie J. Block
Glinda - Kristin or JLT or Kate Reinders
Fiyero - Norbert or Joey McIntyre
Wizard - David Garrison hands down
Morrible - Carole Shelley
Boq - Rob Sapp
Nessarose - Michelle Federer or Heidi Kettenring
Videos