Gypsy--why am I not surprised you didn't see the Phantom movie?

Though I am a bit more surprised you never saw Angels in America.
(But I'm even more surprised he was in A-Team, not that it makes me want to see it more...)
He must have been around 25 when I saw him in the Carousel tour in 1996. For me the age worked--I think, especially given the fact that Carousel is set in the late 19th century (don't quote me on that, but I always assumed it was around the 1880s), having a mid 20s Billy makes sense, age wise, even if he often seems to be played older. I thought he was great, though judging from the cast album and video clips, Hayden probably acted the role better--he seems hard to beat, and my memories are pretty hazy.
He did play the role, perhaps, with more of a sense of doom, or an acceptance that his life would end badly, from the start anyway, which I suppose plays into what others have said about the way Patrick often plays roles. Which is why I was curious how he played Curly on Broadway, a role that really doesn't have that element at all, so it's interesting to see that Letterman clip of the Broadway cast. He does seem to play it with slightly less full on swagger than, say, Hugh.
(Speaking of Full Monty one of Patrick's "go to" stories every time he's on a talk show is about the time that apparently the lighting cue for the strip number was mishandled and his future wife, in the audience, did get to see the full monty).