I've seen DRS twice at the Imperial and its quite obvious that NOTHING compares to live theatre. I think that Norbert was far from awful, maybe some of you need to get new televisions or speakers, and its true that out of context the song doesn't make as much sense, but really I think that was true of all of the numbers on the tonys. Unless you do an opening number, such as Spelling Bee or Avenue Q last year, the song makes little to no sense. As for making people want to see the show, none of you seem able to come up with a better song, which makes me think that no matter what you wouldn't be happy b/c it would make no sense out of context, since all of the songs are closely tied to the plot. Personally, I thought that Sweet Charity had the worst performance. As for Spamalot, I saw the show and loved it, but their performance did nothing for those who are not already interested in the show. It was MUCH worse than the live version and once again the actors seemed confused (David Hyde Pierce came in early on his line before the feet took off). I think that the combined 8 performances, Tony pressure, and being taken out of their element add to the disjointed and subpar feel of most of the numbers. Bottomline, Norbert deserved his Tony, no one is aruguing that, and clearly there are some people who GBS sparked interest in the show in and others not. I know several people who saw that performance and thought he was amazing and are excited to see the show. It was far from awful, and please do not question my taste, b/c I have seen the show and I have seen a lot of shows and I don't just like everything I see (i.e. I like Wicked, but I though Defying Gravity at the Tony's last year wasn't very good, mostly due to context and Idina's nervousness making her voice waver and crack). For those of you who haven't seen DRS, or any of nominated Best New Musicals, I highly recommend that you do, you will not regret it.
"With any part you play, there is a certain amount of yourself in it. There has to be, otherwise it's just not acting. It's lying." ~ Johnny Depp