There was also a very nice review of Lennon/McCartney songs in London called All You Need is Love. The arrangements were outstanding. With a good designer and a good choreographer, I think it would do very well on Broadway. Much like Smokey Joe's Cafe. Personally, I can't get interested in the show Lennon at all.
I don't see anything wrong with jukebox musicals. They are reviews (which no one seems to moan about) with books. Remember Ain't Misbehavin', Eubie, Sophisticated Ladies, Smokey Joe's Cafe, and Play On (which was actually a jukebox musical years before Mamma Mia)? The only reason people don't complain about those is that in most cases, the music was considered older and more classic (with the exception of Smokey Joe's which is the same period as All Shook Up). So why does everyone get in such a huff? If reviews with books are so taboo (almost a jukebox musical), then why aren't reviews reviled? Wouldn't they be considered a step down?
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian