I would definitely recommend "On the Town". Great performances all around (especially from the grossly underrated Tony Yazbeck) and wonderful dancing throughout. I'm still thinking about that dream ballet... Plus, because the Lyric is (sadly) never full, you can likely get a great seat at a great price (I got one of the $20 lottery seats via TodayTix for a 1pm Sunday matinee).
I'm probably one of the few who found "On the 20th Century" to be just okay. My friend and I went in really excited -- it was both our first times seeing Kristin Chenoweth live -- and each of us independently left the theater thinking, "Well that was...cute" and not much more. Kristin did not surprise beyond her typical shenanigans, and Peter Gallagher was disappointingly underwhelming. While I will admit that there were some great numbers ("Life is Like a Train" and "Babbette" come to mind), they were few and far between. I'm almost embarrassed to admit that I rested my eyelids a bit during the second act from boredom tiredness...which I never do at musicals on Broadway.
I was going to recommend "The King and I" next, but I just saw that you had the good judgment to include it already on your itinerary.
You won't be disappointed.
Whatever you choose, have a blast! As an out-of-towner myself, I can relate to the excitement of a planned Broadway trip.
Updated On: 5/28/15 at 01:39 PM