American Idol this Week — Page 25

Me too - I thought she was amazing.

Jason needs to pack his bags

Jasnon's given up.

Syesha was the best tonight.


STILL don't understand the praise Pork Chop gets. he's NOT THAT GOOD.

Cook had one of his weakest nights and was still great.


The final 2 will be Pork Chop and Syesha. (jason's clearly gone as long as he can without marijuana and it's begun to affect his performance and Cook isn't the David America loves, which boggles my mind)

David A was definitely the best tonight. I still don't necessarily want him to win though.

No one this season really grabbed my interest and made me a die hard fan. I didn't vote once this season.

WTF???????

David A was definitely the best tonight.

THIS MAKES NO SENSE. he was boring, uninteresting ad repetitive. STOP WITH THE GOD DAMN RUNS IN EVERY SONG. Its unnecessary and doesn't sound good.


Try singing something that isnt an elevator version of a famous song.

Updated On: 5/6/08 at 09:45 PM

When Sam Cooke sings this song my throat hurts and my eyes fill. If anyone is unfamiliar with it, give it a listen. You'll be glad you did.

With Syesha...nothin.' Absolutely ALL of the meaning is lost for me. She just doesn't have the ability to move me.

I completely agree with you Blueroses. Syesha has never been able to show emotion when she sings. All that crying she did during the judges critique needed to be shown while she was singing. Although i don't care for her, Jason is even worse and should finally get the boot. I still don't understand how he was ever in the top 12.

oy, how can you not remember a line from Mister Tambourine man?? That was pathetic. I swear Jason is either an airhead or high. He just stands there grinning no matter what. NO matter what! Or is he just so damn cool? Of course we know why he's still there-he's hot and the little girls love him. Me too.

I can't see David A. as an American Idol. I don't think he has the social skills yet.

---

So I'm worried about David Cook. Simply because his "off night" really wasn't THAT off at all. He still was great- his usual awesome self. But... for HIM, it was just OK, and that's the worst place to be. The people who do terribly generally get pity votes and popularity votes from their fanbases. The people who do incredibly get legitimate votes. But the people who just have good- but not GREAT- nights get left in it.

I *think* it'll still be alright, but... please, for anyone who's a David C fan and still wants him to be in this thing, VOTE VOTE VOTE!! DON'T assume he's safe because he's really, really not! In fact I think there are quite a few people who seem to think Syesha did better than him. And even though I DO think that with any luck Jason will go tonight, .. he has a really big fanbase still, and his doing awefully tonight is only going to make them vote more.


So yeah.. maybe it's just superstition because the top 4th spot seemes to be the most cursed of all (Tamyra Grey, Latoya London, AND Chris Daughtry- all sent home 4th when they were some of the top contenders), but.. yeah. I'm worried. haha


I'm also worried by the fact that.. he seemed a little bit disconnected tonight. And that is NOT like him. It makes me worry about if something maybe got worse on the AC front :/ I really, really hope not for his sake! That would be such terrible timing, as if it isn't a hard enough situation already! But that was kind of my first thought when I saw how.. sad he looked tonight. It's just not like him to not put much effort into his performances. And his "not putting much effort" wasn't like Jason where it's like "meh, I just don't care anymore. This thing is lame". It was like... you could tell he WANTED to be in the zone, and he was really angry at himself for NOT being, but something just seemed wrong. Which, given the current AC circumstances, makes me worry.



as for the others:

Syesha- she's good, she is, but she's just ridiculously unoriginal

Jason- poor thing, he is just so not IN it anymore! I think he's given up. But I really do feel bad for him. He seemed really embarrased by how poorly he did tonight, and... he doesn't seem to get embarrased easily. At all. lol

David A- Ok, I'm not even a huge fan of his anymore, but I will give credit where credit is due. He was the strongest of the night. With David C coming in second, even on his WORST night thus far. haha

---

Updated On: 5/7/08 at 10:23 PM

I think David C. was the best tonight.
David A. was good, but boring.

And I must be the only one, but I kind of liked Jason's second performance, even though he forgot the words. I think he even sounded a little bit like Dylan, in a nasally sort of way.
I do, however, think his first performance was so bad, that he will probably be going home next week.

David Cook is my favorote. Has been and will remain so. I enjoyed him last night as always... But gotta say HUNGRY LIKE THE WOLF was just... OK.

Jason... I have NO IDEA how he's gotten this far AT ALL.

Syesha was great VERY impressed.

David A... BORING BORING BORING

---

Jayson has come this far, not on talent-but bec of his fangirl base. This is not a talent contest, but a popularity contest. Look for David C. or Sayesha to go tonight...Jayson should unpack his bags, the girls will save him. This show has lost it's credabilty after last season, when the old Grey man won.
Where the hell were his fans when his album was released? It tanked!
It kills me how they get 30 million votes for the winner and his debut album bombs...
I would love to see the top 2: The two Davids, but I don't think it's going to happen.

"If Jason does not go home this week, then the voting is even more fixed than everyone thought."

Not necessarily. I do think they f--k with the numbers, but I wouldn't be surprised if Jason gets more actual support, fair or not. He probably has a bigger fanbase than Syesha.

"Jason may not have performed well at all, but there's no denying he isn't a terribly entertaining pothead."

Which is why I'd be perfectly okay with him outlasting Syesha.

Jane, for you. Another one:

http://cgi.ebay.com/TABLOACH-OOAK-KELLY-TOMMY-POCKET-SIZE-JASON-CASTRO_W0QQitemZ170217072636QQihZ007QQcategoryZ201QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem#ebayphotohosting