It's not freedom from religion. It is freedom from a state-established religion.
Presenting a picture of a religious symbol in a public school would be just that.
Ok, picture of Muhammad is a bad example because Muhammad is not pictorially represented in Islam.
But how would any Christian feel if the Islamic crescent moon or creed or the Star of David were presented in their schools?
Probably the same way I might have felt - I'm Jewish - had a picture of Christ been presented in my public school: marginalized, unrepresented, oppressed, less than or other than an American. Why would anyone want to inflict that on anyone?
And that is why it would and also should be unconstitutional.
(Of course, I assume we are talking about presenting a specific religious symbol in wide public view in a school, and not just presenting religious symbols in a specific limited way relevant to a course of study - e.g., a discussion of Joan of Arc might of course include representations of her wearing a cross, a study of the Crusades might include depictions of Christian and Muslim symbols, the flags of nations which - because they don't share an equivalent American freedom from an established religion (Saudi Arabia, Israel, Denmark) - contain religious symbols can certainly be depicted during a discussion of them, etc.)
***
Why does the constitution require freedom from a state-established religion? Because a great many people came to the American colonies (including many of our founders' families) to escape religious tyranny and find freedom to practice their own faiths. They wouldn't want children to be educated in public schools which feature a specific religious symbol. They would believe that to be emblematic of the oppressive systems they were running away from in which they were discriminated against if they did not practice the state religion.
If families want their children to be educated amid religious doctrine and its iconography, they are free to place their children in parochial schools.
But you knew that, OP, didn't you?
Updated On: 2/5/13 at 08:09 AM