Kinda felt like I couldn't keep belittling this movie unless I actually plunked down my shekels and saw it in a theater.
Which is what I did yesterday. And now I feel entitled to belittle it again all over the place. The thing gets me SO ANGRY at points! Ya know that scene in the trailer where Danny throws the first brick in the revolution? Well, it's even worse in the context of the full scene-- Danny has just escaped a scene being pimped out to a J Edgar Hoover type in horrid Dame Edna drag (mixing the movie's 2 favorite villains-- middle-aged male predators, and really trashy drag). He's run back to the Stonewall Inn where he and his friends are kicked out of the bar during yet another raid, to the cheers of a swelling crowd of gays in the street outside, who wait expectantly for something, anything, to explode. So our FICTIONAL hero Danny makes a huge speech to the mute crowd rallying them to fight back-- and Danny looks down to find someone has somehow put a brick in his hand. When Danny throws that brick through the window, he is literally cast as the ring leader for the whole revolt. Talk about revolting!!
Yeah, Jonny Beauchamp is terrific as Puerto Rican street hustler Ray. But that could be because he's surrounded by a lot of actors who seem really uncomfortable to be there, among them Ron Perlman and Jonathan Rhys Myers, who being middle aged, are both cast as unreliable or downright evil characters in the story of gay liberation. (The movie's postscript takes pains to explain how Perlman's real-life character underwent a dramatic about-face later and became a real hero in the gay rights fight down the road.)
What makes me angriest about this film? The fact that in the last reel, the damn thing still made me cry real tears, at the sight of the 1970 Gay Liberation March that turned the 4 days outside Stonewall into the watershed event we know today. And you will be more moved by the postscript outlining the fates of the real-life principals here than anything Roland Emmerich stages in the body of the film. What a wasted opportunity to tell this story without the Hollywood cliches.
Updated On: 9/26/15 at 05:08 PM