Oh, I agree, Chloe, he definitely can. He sounded adorable. For me, it comes down to... say, hypothetically, in a concert setting, he could draw on the more legit side of his range and do really nice renditions of a lot of "more traditional" theater music. But the knot for me occurs in terms of actually
playing a role, and sounding believably like that "type" of character. To me, there's a big difference between acknowledging that he could sing a character's songs well and then extrapolating that to say he could play the role. So while he can sing and sound fine on Cliff's songs, I don't know that I'd cast him as Cliff, because it doesn't fit the sort of standard aesthetic. I think a lot of roles in shows like, say, Cabaret, require that standard, pretty "theater" voice, which Adam just doesn't have, you know? He got away with playing the Emcee, but that's a role that just breaks all the rules. To me, "more traditional" on him isn't necessarily traditional enough to fit that mold. I think I'm referring most directly to older shows, though, for what it's worth. I don't even know that he'd be interested in that sort of thing, but it all comes to mind.
Craww, yes, there is a big difference between those two. It's the type of material. But I'm not sure I agree with what you said after that. I think that certain kinds of material, while they can be handled by various different types, ask for specific types of vocals. I mean, you wouldn't put like, Brian Stokes Mitchell in a rock opera, would you? In a show like Aida, yeah, I think the material does demand it, whereas Chess is something that could go either way -- rock vocals or more "legit" vocals. You have a rock score, it should ideally be sung by rock singers. Of course, someone like Will Chase has a more traditional voice than Adam does, but it's still pretty distinctly along the rock lines.
Ash, you're right. But when this sort of thing comes up, I consistently contest that my level of being critical is in a direct correlation with how much I like the performer and his work.
A work of art is an invitation to love.