I really like 'Moving Too Fast' and 'Shiksa Goddess' from 'The Last Five Years'. I'm a lassie who sings a rather good high soprano, but I've managed to cultivate a rather decent tenor voice (that I've been widely complimented on (if I had a singing teacher, she'd hate me)) singing along to this show.
Actually, here's a tangent for you. When you're singing audition songs, you should really choose a song that matches you. If you're a female teenage soprano, you sing a song suitable for a female teenage soprano, perhaps something from 'Oklahoma!'. If you decide you're going to sing something that's not traditionally associated with your type, you need a damn good reason (for instance, a transposed 'How Glory Goes' from 'Floyd Collins', with the two-part explanation of a) you don't have to be a 38-year old man trapped in a cave to be fearful and accepting of your impending death and b) if it's good enough for Audra McDonald, it's good enough for me).
And also, if you're choosing two audition songs, you should go for contrast. So a nice legit-voice ballad from the Golden Age could be presented against a rockin' belty up-tempo song from something since the '70s but that hasn't been on Broadway in the last five years.
Anyone who's still with me, please ponder this question. If I found an awesome wailing blow-'em-out-of-the-water tenor song that didn't specifically go "HEY! I'M A MAN SINGING A MAN'S SONG!" and had a universal enough theme that I could justify just about anyone singing it (hey, maybe something like 'Being Alive', but a little less overdone), would that be a great idea to contrast a legit-soprano ballad? Or would that be SO contrasty that the auditioners would hate me?
And is it EVER acceptable to present 'Too Many Daves!' by Dr. Seuss as one of your audition monologues?