"I gave you an example of what I found endearing. Then you replied and amended your request that, well, the example would satisfy you IF it had happened in the last year and a half."
It wasn't an amended request, but a rhetorical question I did not expect you to answer. And I'm not implying that his moment of endearment HAD to occur within a specific time frame, I meant that had it been seen more frequently or recently, then back stories would be unnecessary. But your post made it seem like one endearing back story from a couple of years ago need never be repeated when people question the behavior of a couple of years of bitterness. I said if he had more balanced posts it would probably bother me LESS, but I would still hate unprovoked attacks for sport.
"And more importantly, you can't ask for an example and then complain that it's not recent enough and expect somebody to comply with THAT request."
I'm not asking anyone to comply with anything. Obviously, people here will do what they want. Some get away with it and others don't. I started this point of the discussion with you because you said "people get pegged as nice OR mean" and it may because at the point they come in, that could very well be the case. In the case of DP, it could have been any time in the last year or year-and-a-half. Come to think of it, I do remember him posting something to help a kid with the issue of coming out. It still doesn't change the fact that he is intentionally cruel most of the time.
Nobody has to debate with me or comply with me or agree with me. I know you're fond of the "kill or be killed" approach to message boards, but I don't always feel that way. It's not so much defending someone else as it is using Liquid Plum-r to stop the sh*t from pouring all over the place. People bitch about Wicked threads and I bitch about this.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian