HenryTDobson said: "Great show, as always. So many talented youngsters, excited to see where they all land.
I think both winners were the best of the bunch. I wish someone would help with song selection for the finalists because some of these songs are wayyyyy over these high school kids' heads. I think Samia picked the most relatable song for a high schooler, which is why she excelled (and of course had excellent vocals as well). I do find it confusing how students are able to attend the Jimmys multiple times - this was Samia's third time there, a finalist every year she appeared. Clearly she's great but it would be nice to spread the love around a bit....
It's always interesting to see what shows are common in high schools. Hadestown is clearly a favorite across the country...."
IMO, Hadestown is a favorite because the young lovers are so relatable to high schoolers, as well as the score.
I agree with you about "some of these songs are wayyyyy over these high school kids' heads". Jake James was able to create a convincing portrayal of adult emotions, though. I think the challenge some of these selections present are what (literally) separates the men from the boys (or the women from the girls, as the case may be).
Updated On: 6/23/26 at 12:35 AM