My lottery seat a few weeks ago was up there, and I thought the view was fine. It's a small-ish theater, so it didn't feel as nose-blood as balcony seats in the New Amsterdam, that was just miserable.
My friend, who's usually an orchestra seat snub ended up buying the $45 seat when we didn't get rush (I didn't because I'd already seen it & they only had one for that price) and even she said the view was totally okay.
But I do agree, it is a bit silly to have rush/lottery if you only save $6 (plus fees if you would otherwise buy online). From what I heard though is that you can get mezz or orch seats now, it's not all up there anymore (depending on availability)