I don't have a problem with Jackman's singing in this clip. He was the right choice for the critical role of Jean. He is both immediately likable, has great presence, is believable as both a hardened criminal and loving father, and he can sing and sing well.
He may have learned how to sing using faulty techniques employed by amateurs with zero talent, but he's a talented guy who made it work, and has created for himself (and us) a career rich in his craft.
I forced myself to watch this clip. I'm glad I did.
Instead of writing a dissertation to entertain y'all, I will just add my first, immediate impression.
Pros:
Overall: Amazingly well executed, well directed, effectively handled and adapted for the screen. Performances are also well thought-out, and creatively adapted for the screen.
Cons:
The orchestra sounds like a disembodied ghost hovering over the actor's heads. I hope it's just this clip's mixing and it has more presence in its cinema release, like it's an actual part of what is going on in front of us. Music in musicals isn't an excuse to sing. It's an integral part of the proceedings. When the factory bitch interjects with her suggestions about Fantine to the Foreman, so should those gossipy John Cameron woodwinds. They should be mixed to be at one with the singer and the underlying message or theme of the moment. It shouldn't suddenly surge in volume when nobody's singing or only to punctuate a point or emphasize a shot. The story and even the character is IN the music!
I liked it. I'd love it if they'd fix the mixing problem.
The Orchestrations:
It's true to the original John Cameron orchestration.
It's true to the original John Cameron orchestration.
It's true to the original John Cameron orchestration.
It's true to the original John Cameron orchestration.
It's true to the original John Cameron orchestration.
It's true to the original John Cameron orchestration.
It's true to the original John Cameron orchestration.
It's true to the original John Cameron orchestration.
Which means it flowed well, is cohesive, has character and balls, and isn't a reedy piece of sh*t, cliched mess.
It is mixed in with snippets of the new crap orchestration. And I just LOVE how those moments jump out at you and sound like they belong in another show and are reedy and sound cartoonishly bright and then John Cameron's work comes in and smothers those snippets with awesomeness.
I can't express more love for the added bit between Valjean and Javert. Just great.
Recreation of original John Cameron orchestration to "On My Own" by yours truly. Click player below to hear.
Updated On: 12/20/12 at 07:38 PM