I can't believe I find myself somewhat agreeing with After Eight here.
I disliked A Steady Rain and found it to be quite a chore to sit through. The two of them had I'll Eat You Last syndrome and sat in chairs on opposite sides of the stage all evening. They related a police case that wasn't all that interesting, and certainly wasn't presented in a dramatic way.
I can only speak for myself and don't think After Eight should be attempting to intuit what audiences in general thought of it either, but it was disappointing to see such a seemingly capable star sit there all night.
Betrayal is leagues better than A Steady Rain, but I disagree that Craig has the better of the two male roles. The letter scene really feels like his only moment and the rest of the play belongs to Weisz and especially Spall.
After seeing Craig in his two Broadway outings I think he has talent, but when he comes back for a third time I hope it's in something completely different.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!