EthelMae said: "I gotta say I'm a little tired of reading here that Ms. Peters is this 'n that based on whether or not the title number got a standing ovation or not. I don't remember her getting one the night I saw her and I thought she was lovely in the role. Additionally, Ethel Merman never got a standing ovation after the title song the 4 times I saw her in the role. As we a know these days, standing ovations are usually for the audience member who shelved out premium prices for a ticket and wants to make their night a night THEY will never forget. I love this production and I have never stood after the Dolly number-Ms. Midler included.
I enjoyed Midler and Murphy more than Ms. Peters myself but the show is still worth going to and to be enjoyed.
Couple of points.
1. ABSOLUTELY agree with your basic premise. Standing ovations and 'whooping' have become a joke, particularly SOs. I remember the days when your hands could hurt so much just from applauding something great; when a SO occurred, it was a rarity and memorable. It meant something...not anymore. I refer to this as 'The American Idolization of America', which is not as bad as 'The Apprenticization of America', but still sucks.
2. I actually thought that Ethel Merman was one of the worst Dollys I ever saw. To me, she stood center stage, sang her songs, and went through the motions in all other respects. Naturally, she was the only Dolly that I saw in the original run who received a SO...because she was Ethel Merman, not because she was better than anyone else in the role.
3. I have not seen BP yet...I hope to see her in early June. Am expecting to love her in the role...will be disappointed if I do not. Who knows, maybe a curtain call SO -- which will clearly occur -- will even be deserved.