Big Fish

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

Big Fish

Posted: 5/18/17 at 4:28am

In deciding whether or not to audition for my local community theater's upcoming production of Big Fish this summer, I watched a bootleg recording of the Chicago try out. I do know the first act was heavily revised for Broadway, however I can't quite wrap my head around the fact that it did not receive a single Tony nomination! Other than the fact that it was a show that flopped in the fall and was forgotten come spring, anyone have any insight into why it got no Tony love? While there are a few duds in the score, there are also some truly stunning melodies, and I think Norbert's performance was beyond worthy of a nod. Bobby and Kate were also quite stunning, and I also find it sad they were forgotten. I just don't quite get the exclusion, especially in a pretty bland season....

Big Fish

Posted: 5/18/17 at 4:52am

Where are you doing BIG FISH? I was just cast as Edward Bloom in a local production of the show in WV, myself. I also watched the Chicago production pre-audition and was surprised at the total lack of nominations myself. Such a beautiful show full of heart and humor. I am sorry I missed seeing it when it was on Broadway.

<-- Tevye, FIDDLER ON THE ROOF, March 2018

Big Fish

Posted: 5/18/17 at 6:05am

I remember seeing Big Fish the weekend my grandpa passed, and I was so moved. Thought Norbert was excellent (as always) and the music was beautiful. Was heartbroken when it didn't get any nominations and closed so quickly.

Big Fish

Posted: 5/18/17 at 10:20am

I attended the Chicago tryout and wasn't surprised it didn't fare well with the Tonys, though I thought it might do slightly better than Bullets Over Broadway. But the show opened in October and was closed before New Year's Eve. It was long forgotten by the time the nominations were announced. Personally, I thought it only had a couple of good songs, the best of which was cut (The River Between Us). The staging was often a mess, often relying too heavily on projections. The whole Stevie Knicks witch in the woods number and scene was not only bad, we couldn't make out the projections that foreshadowed the ending from where we were sitting. That Showdown nightmare sequence should have been cut early on. But then, I wasn't a huge fan of the film, either. I didn't feel like the musical really added much to the mostly tension-free story. It's just a bit too sugary for my tastes. I do like Fight the Dragons, so there's that.

"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian

Big Fish

Posted: 5/18/17 at 11:11am

I was really looking forward to this. Interestingly, I mildly enjoyed Act 1 and HATED Act 2. My wife and friend did not like Act 1 and all, but liked Act 2, so go figure. In my case, I just got tired of the whimsy. I also didn't think the score was good.

As I recall, it had no advance, no stars (Norbert is not a box office attraction), was based on a movie that most people forgot, did not get good reviews, and was whimsical. The Neil Simon was too large a theatre for whimsy, which belongs in the Booth or the Helen Hayes (or whatever it is called these days).

Big Fish

Posted: 5/18/17 at 11:53am

I saw the Chicago production and I remember thinking the score was the weakest piece of the show. It just didn't capture that quirky, mysterious feel of the film (which I adored, with the exception? of Billy Crudup who felt miscast). If it closed several months before nominations, I'm not surprised it was forgotten.

Big Fish

Posted: 5/18/17 at 11:56am

I can't help but think how amazing a JRB score would have been for this show.

My father (AIDS) My sister (AIDS) My uncle and my cousin and her best friend (AIDS, AIDS, AIDS) The gays and the straights And the white and the spades

Big Fish

Posted: 5/18/17 at 1:01pm

It was a big, loud, brassy, one production number after another kind of an affair. Forgotten thirty minutes after I left the theatre. Performances and vocals excellent. Shame Bobby Steggert's career didn't take off.

Big Fish

Posted: 5/18/17 at 2:17pm

very entertaining and fun show. saw in NYC, Norbert and the cast were fantastic most memorable songs included Be the hero, fight the dragons, and daffodils-I thought the score was much stronger than some of the shows nominated this year

loved the original movie, thought it was a solid adaptation for the book. great sets and costumes

Think the show suffered most from a fall/winter launch and the dreaded poor review from new york times....

Wish i could see it with OBC again....

← Back to Message Board

View all Videos

Tickets From $70

Tickets From $77

Tickets From $106

Tickets From $159