>Given that the reviews weren't necessarily raves (but not WONDERLAND bad) and has a lot of steep competition, it manages to break the $1 Million Club and fill a good majority of its house. I'd call that a smash hit.<
There's "hit" and "smash hit" and you can determine it by looking at some of the other figures which illustrate how a show is filling its seats. Priscilla is performing nicely, filling a large theatre to 88% capacity last week. That's not an inconsiderable feat. It has an average ticket of $83.86. Healthy figure, but it also means there's some discounting going on and there's also the figure that Priscilla is performing to 68.78% of its gross potential of $1,400,000 (the figure of what the show could generate with every seat sold at its full value).
For the same week, Mormon has an average ticket price of $111.59, showing very little discounting, if any, and played to 98.90% of its gross potential of $985,000. So I think if one wants to differentiate, Mormon is playing at "smash hit" level figures with Priscilla playing to "hit" figures.
Begin at the beginning and go on till you come to the end: then stop.