Mr. Wormwood said: "hearthemsing22 said: "That'd be great for you. But how many other people would do that? How many other people would be interested? I have a friend who said tours took away Wednesday matinees because they weren't selling. Do you honestly think Broadway would do any better if there were two weekday matinees? And then how would you do the weekend schedule? How would Saturday and Sunday performances work?"
I understand that if it was a more viable option, more shows would do it. Hence, why I said I WISH that happened. I understand the realities of why it doesn't. But sometimes shows do it from time to time so I'd love to see it catch on at some point."
It all depends on the show. HAMILTON and LION KING and WICKED could have all their showtimes at 1pm and 10pm and they'd still be fine.
Changes to a playing schedule often come at a moment of desperation, and if a show is doing badly it won't make a big difference; ABN is in the unique situation of being a "sleeper hit" that could improve but is still making money each week.
Broadway has worked hard over many years to create an infrastructure surrounding the Wednesday matinee to allow shows to succeed: Group sales agents have sort of conditioned buyers that weekday matinees only happen on Wednesday. TKTS Times Square opens at 11am on Wed but is closed until 3pm on Thur, so that won't drive any sales to the Thur shows. It will require other ways of drawing in day-of buyers (flyering teams at the booth on Weds with b.o. discounts for Thurs, etc). I wonder if it became a free-for-all with mats being equally split between Tue/Wed/Thur/Fri, the numbers for all might go down. School groups would probably benefit the most from a 12pm curtain so they can get back back before the end of the actual school day, but schools aren't the primary audience here.
From the cast-standpoint, 6 shows in 4 days can be a lot more tiresome than 5 shows in 4 days, especially for a vocally-challenging show (HARMONY and BEAUTIFUL NOISE will have 2 shows Thurs, with just a matinee on Weds). That's not a reason not to do it, but it's a consideration.