CindersGolightly said: "I agree, JBroadway, but I also think it has to do with many people not seeing any shows and just voting for their favorite people. From an unbiased point of view, I do think Annaleigh deserves the two awards she was nominated for, and I do think she deserves a Tony nomination for "Sylvia", but if she were to win - which she won't - I would be shocked, and felt it would be undeserved. She gave an incredible performance with some of the best physicality I've seen in ages, but compared to Lupita and Michele this season, it's like she's a new musical up against "Hamilton". There's no way. Anyway, I hate these awards, too, but it always gives me some Annaleigh to look forward to, which is good."
Yes, I agree with most of what you just said. I definitely think Annaleigh is a general audience favorite, and also that most of the people voting for her probably haven't seen all the other contenders. I didn't see Sylvia (on purpose), so I can't speak directly to the likelihood of her winning this year. Especially, since I was completely dumbfounded that she won last year. So what do I know?