Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Buying show tickets far in advance

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1

Buying show tickets far in advance

I usually can’t do this, or choose not to, but for a variety of reasons I have gone against the grain and bought tickets to a bunch of plays and musicals well in advance. I realized the other day that I am up 10, and my wife and I are seeing the first one tonight at the Berkeley Rep, Liberation.

I am seeing John Proctor is the Villain at ACT in San Francisco next weekend, then - for the first time - got a Berkeley Rep three-show package in part to get good seats at reasonable prices for The Interestings. (The others we picked, in case you’re curious, are Covenant and Meet the Cartozians - which my partner and I won’t see until in next June.)

In the meantime, I already have bought tickets to five Broadway musicals for a New York City trip in early April - Spring Awakening, Evita, Paddington, The Sound of Music, and Warriors.

This buy-in-advance spree goes against recent trends and my own inclinations. It’s possible I overpaid for some of these shows. But we were treating others to three of them (Evita, Paddington, The Sound of Music) and the other two are in pretty high demand when we’re there, Warriors in particular. The only one that we’re paying more than $200-per-ticket for (barely) is Evita. The least expensive show is Spring Awakening ($79 for tickets in the second-to-last row of a small theater). Everything else is in the mid-100s, which meant some sacrifices in seat quality in two cases.

We will see other shows here and on our New York City trip, but I’m not inclined to make too many more advance purchases. I have reminded myself that my three favorite shows of last year’s New York City trip were all plays, but I will wait to see how the spring season shakes out.

I realize there are many theatergoers across the country who have subscriptions to entire seasons, so I am not doing anything that unusual. But the combination of my inability to plan too far in advance as well as my spouse’s preference for picking some shows on a whim (she loves getting rush or TKTS booth tickets and resists my urge to plan) has meant I haven’t done it very often, and certainly not months in advance. Locally, it’s almost always easy enough to get tickets on the day of the show or shortly in advance.

Are most of you doing more waiting to get tickets than you did a few years ago? Buying early often doesn’t seem like much of an advantage, aside from seat quality in some cases. Outside of major hits or celebrity shows, it usually seems safe to wait. (There is always an exception like Death of a Salesman, which felt a little pricey when I bought a ticket but turned out to be a bargain after word of mouth hit.)

But this Broadway season does have a few musicals that, for a variety of reasons, have buzz - at least for when we will be there in early April. That will undoubtedly change once people see the shows, but it felt safer to buy early this time. Is anyone else adopting different strategies for some shows this year?

Updated On: 11/8/26 at 04:27 AM

#2

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

If one or two shows are "must see" anchors for a trip and advance prices are not wholly unreasonable, we tend to buy those in advance. We then keep close tabs on the pricing for other possibilities, looking for TodayTix deals or any other offers.

We also tend to buy any LCT member tix or Public tickets well in advance since they are easily changed.

Time of year influences our thinking a bit as well. For an upcoming five-day trip in early January we've only purchased Other Desert Cities and Much Ado About Nothing because getting good seats and good prices in January usually is not difficult.

One other variable that makes an advance purchase more likely is a less common show time: Thursday matinee, Sunday evening, etc.
#3

Buying show tickets far in advance

I also have been buying early for my next trip to NYC at Easter. Kind of crazy because I still have a few days to go before I leave for this year's visit. Some of the shows it just felt like I should secure seats early. I went with a cheap as possible for Warriors, even though I know sight lines might be bad. On the other hand I ponied up for a good orchestra seat to a preview of Paddington. I liked that ATG had something new - cancel for any reason insurance. I paid for that because who knows what might happen? The trip was over 5 months away when I made that purchase, but time moves quickly.

Locally, I sat down one day in September and planned out what shows I wanted to see here over the holidays, as that's when there tends to be the most going on. Then I spent a wack of money in one sitting. But now plans are set & I won't be scrounging around later trying to figure out what to do, or upset if I can't get in to something the day I want - at home I pretty much only see shows on Saturday nights as I don't have the energy to go.out mid-week, and forget about Friday night!

But I'm a planner. I've already got vacation plans made for next July, and have started reading up on where I might go if I do go to Mexico next Fall, and I've started making plans for Easter 2028 which lands in April that year.


...

Updated On: 11/8/26 at 08:13 AM

#4

Buying show tickets far in advance

I am local and very last minute, I try to get the cheapest seats in the orchestra or front mezzanine that I can so I never buy in advance. However, if I was coming from afar, I would for sure buy Paddington and Warriors tickets in advance. I may buy Paddington for myself, even though I already saw it in London. I imagine the tickets will be scarce once the public sees how great it is.

#5

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

I remember buying Music Man with Foster Sutton and Hugh Jackman the minute they dropped. Then Covid happened and they pushed it back, then back again, then back again, and back a fourth time as the pandemic kept delaying everything. This was a paper physical ticket at the time, so I have 8 paper tickets in my box of Playbills for that one show! LOL.
I think out-of-town folks are fine buying what you want far in advance. If you are paying hundreds for a flight, hundreds per night for a hotel room. hundreds per day for food and drink, etc .... is spending $250 on a ticket to know you are in with the seat you want ... or rolling the dice you can get a $79 ticket maybe last second .. is that really worth it for you? To each his own.
#6

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

carlisle14 said: "I remember buying Music Man with Foster Sutton and Hugh Jackman the minute they dropped. Then Covid happened and they pushed it back, then back again, then back again, and back a fourth time as the pandemic kept delaying everything. This was a paper physical ticket at the time, so I have 8 paper tickets in my box of Playbills for that one show! LOL.
I think out-of-town folks are fine buying what you want far in advance. If you are paying hundreds for a flight, hundreds per night for a hotel room. hundreds per day for food and drink, etc .... is spending $250 on a ticket to know you are in with the seat you want ... or rolling the dice you can get a $79 ticket maybe last second .. is that really worth it for you? To each his own.
"

Same here. I bought TMM tickets the day they went on sale, and then Covid, and we know the rest. Ha, ha. By the time my friend and I saw the show for the first time, it was April 2022. The morning that tickets went on sale for "Hello, Dolly!" in September 2016, Telecharge crashed due to the high demand. Luckily, my ticket purchase happened before their system went down.

Now that we can go online to either Telecharge, Ticketmaster and Broadwaydirect to see how shows are selling, it's an easy decision to not have to buy tickets in advance and get either a rush or standing room ticket for the show. Been doing that now for quite a few years. When "Chess" went on sale, I bought tickets the morning of, and Telecharge crashed that day, too. For both "Ragtime" and "Oh, Mary," and the multiple times I've seen both shows, I purchased those tickets in advance.

My last few trips to NYC, the majority of my tickets were either rush, standing room, or through Audience Rewards.

When "Miss Saigon" opened in NYC in March 1991, I purchased my ticket well over a year ahead of time via mail in ordering. Back when you would mail in your order with a check, and pick the performance you wanted, and kept your fingers crossed that what you ultimately got sent back to you, is what you wanted. Oh, such a long time ago.

Updated On: 11/10/26 at 12:41 PM

#8

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

I’ve been burned this season with buying off broadway tix in advance. Anon, The Visitors, and The Heart all papered. Luckily I snagged the tix and sold my purchased ones. There’s no incentive to buy in advance off broadway when so much gets papered, it’s very sad.

#9

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

I always book way in advance. It's for sure bit me in terms of paying more than if I had waited and snagged it on TKTs or TDF, but coming in for a limited time frame I don't have that luxury. I am flying out tomorrow for a week and almost every show I have had tickets to for months. I'm also going back out in April and have almost every available time slot purchased already. Occasionally I'll leave an open slot for something last minute, but usually there is enough that interests me to buy in advance
#10

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

I'd say buying tickets for regional theatres and Broadway shows is a bit different. Those local subscription theatres rely on subscribers, so getting a subscription or package is a good thing even if the show is further away. BTW I got a full season subscription for Berkeley Rep too. Some shows at BR or ACT go on TodayTix for discount, but some popular shows may sell out too, so I think it's a good thing to lock in.

For Broadway shows, I tend to buy a must see show ticket in advance. Then as my slots start to fill up, I check the performance dates/time to see how other shows will fit in the trip. I don't usually do rush or lottery but I often use TKTS or TDF to get discounted tickets for other shows.
#11

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

OP here. We bought tickets for the sixth show on our upcoming trip, The Odd Couple revival on the final night of our early April trip. As a tourist, traveling across the country, it is difficult to navigate the dueling desires to snag good tickets while leaving room for last-second improvisations. This trip is shaping up to be revival-heavy, but that’s what is dominating Broadway.

Our schedule:

Thursday, April 1: Spring Awakening

Friday, April 2: Evita

Saturday, April 3: Paddington

Sunday, April 4 - open

Monday, April 5 - open

Tuesday, April 6 - The Sound of Music

Wednesday, April 7 (matinee) - Warriors

Wednesday, April 7 (evening) - open

Thursday, April 8 (evening) - The Odd Couple

It is possible we will have time to see a show on the night of our arrival on March 31, depending on our flight and subway transportation. I want to keep Wednesday night free because we still don’t know the full season yet, and Wednesday nights are usually easier. (That was one reason to get The Odd Couple tickets on Thursday, aside from the fact that we were able to get better seats.)

I still think it’s odd to have so many slots full months in advance. But even if I have overpaid for some shows, I suspect that at least one or two will turn out to be a lot more expensive - or with worse seat options, or both - if we had waited.

Updated On: 11/14/26 at 08:32 PM

#13

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

If Damn Yankees on Broadway is half as good as it was here in DC (and I admit to having my reservations about that) I would recommend it highly. We're going around the same time you're in NYC.

#14

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

Oh yes I’ve heard great things about Damn Yankees and they have a show Monday April 5th too. Not that many shows do Mondays.

#15

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

I agree with you are saying about off broadway offerings. I have had the same experience. And it does not seem to be worth buying subscriptions as well unless you would just like to support the theater. I have bought tickets to off broadway shows and then they have ended up on my seat filler clubs for next to nothing.

I would say as far as Broadway goes; buy tickets early if they have major stars in them and limited runs. Seat prices can increase after one or two days of the initial sell date. And early on, there could very well be a possibility of getting a coupon code either in the mail or on social media for previews.

#16

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

After the ground stoppage of all flights Friday I feel better about only being diverted due to bad weather, and getting to the city 4 hours late. I missed a show, but it was an inexpensive ticket for an off-Bwy concert. But it makes me worried for future planning. It was only a few weeks ago that I changed my plans to fly in a couple days earlier. Originally I wasn't arriving until Saturday, and that flight ended up canceled, which probably would have kiboshed the entire trip. I liked that I could add insurance to my Paddington ticket bought through the ATG site. I would like it if insurance could be an added option when buying through Telecharge as well. For March I booked Evita for the night of the day I fly in. I don't see that as being something that will have a lot of availability to try and past date if I run into similar flight delays. It's a gamble I guess.


...
#17

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

DiegoKoch said: "All My Sons should be on that list. If Wanted is still running that should be on the list."

If Wanted is running in April, I’ll vote for you as a write-in on the next Presidential ballot, BroadwayFlash.

#18

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

TX has ticket protection for a fee and I think it is worth it if you are buying a ticket that is a half a year from now or you are flying in to see shows.

#19

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

Because we travel from Australia, I tend to book everything in advance, typically as shows are announced.

Combination of reasons - getting good seats; needing to have our plans somewhat locked in advance and given the expense of the trip, and somewhat limited time, this might sound awful, but I don't want to "waste" vacation time waiting in line for rush tickets.

I do tend to use the discount offers where I can, but I usually just pay full rate for most ("Lost Lear" being the latest example).

#20

Re: Buying show tickets far in advance

inception said: "After the ground stoppage of all flights Friday I feel better about only being diverted due to bad weather, and getting to the city 4 hours late. I missed a show, but it was an inexpensive ticket for an off-Bwy concert. But it makes me worried for future planning. It was only a few weeks ago that I changed my plans to fly in a couple days earlier. Originally I wasn't arriving until Saturday, and that flight ended up canceled, which probably would have kiboshed the entire trip. I liked that I could add insurance to my Paddington ticket bought through the ATG site. I would like it if insurance could be an added option when buying through Telecharge as well. For March I booked Evita for the night of the day I fly in. I don't see that as being something that will have a lot of availability to try and past date if I run into similar flight delays. It's a gamble I guess."

When I had my London trip, I purposely didn't book anything the first day I arrived, just in case my flight was delayed or cancelled. My return flight was cancelled, I left a day later, and I got to get a rush ticket to Stranger Things.

Latest Posts

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $67