Nycat63 said: "James Cromwell at Dolls House Part 2, Bobby Cannavale at Falsettos and Joe Lo Truglio at Front Page, who also happened to be seated next to me during the play and was super nice. Cromwell smiled and waved to those waiting at stage door, Cannavale did not acknowledge anyone, but no one tried to engage him, either. Which I think is appropriate when a celeb is not in the show. "
Not technically a stage door experience since this happened at the Barrow Street Theatre after Buyer and Cellar, but Tony Shaloub was in the audience. He exited into the lobby afterwards with the rest of the audience. I spoke briefly to him when I was waiting for Michael Urie and he walked by me. I was able to tell him how much I enjoyed his work on Monk (I’ve since seen and loved him in The Band’s Visit). He was trying to stay relatively incognito as the lobby was still pretty crowded, but was polite. I thought he left, but after the lobby cleared out and I was only one waiting for Michael Urie (who couldn’t have been lovelier), he came back out (from no doubt going backstage to congratulate Mr. Urie) and initiated a selfie with me (which he had respectfully declined earlier). He said something to the effect of “let’s get that photo now.”