Composers and shows and their contributions — Page 2

TEH,

Funny you mention that, I am reading an academic article right now, and one big point it is trying to make is that Sondheim's librettists never get enough credit. Sondheim himself doesn't even like when people refer to a show as a "Sondheim" show and try to find themes that run through them all, because he feels that if that happens then he is not doing his job and serving the story, and hence the librettists.

Akiva

I believe Sondheim wrote four musicals for Oscar's course, but I am often bad about detail. They were All That Glitters, Mary Poppins, Climb High, and something else?

There's a difference between writing a reprise and writing music thematically. Just because you hear a line of music again doesn't mean it's a reprise. A reprise is when you hear a song in a show again and there's almost nothing different about it, if anything at all. When Sondheim says he's against them it's because he doesn't understand why a character would sing unless they had some cause to, or why they would ever sing the same thing again since they have clearly gone through a lot of growth since the first time they sang that song.

I think this is kind of unfair of him because it's a very general statement and he has used reprises. A Little Night Music reprises Send in the Clowns at the very end. It's justified, so I agree that in places where it is justified, go for it. But it's a little shady to repeat a song for the express purpose of letting the audience hear it again.

FoscasBohemianDream, your statement was a little funny because Oscar Hammerstein wrote the lyrics and book of Showboat, and Rodgers music for Pal Joey.

TheEnchantedHunter, thank you. Sondheim is less the maverick than people accuse him of being. Supremely romantic and brooding, right down to the every note of his music (what unromantic composer could write any of Sweeney Todd?). He just doesn't deal in kitsch, like so many others. There is the difference.

---

""No, Sondheim wasn't the first to write songs for characters, but he was the first to do it so specifically."

Tell that to Harold Hill (Trouble) and Adelaide (Adelaide's Lament) and Tony Esposito (Mama, Mama) and Jud Fry (Lonely Room) and King Mongkut (A Puzzlement) and Henry Higgins (An Ordinary Man) and.....the list goes on. "

Yes, all of those songs are very well written character songs that are quite specific. However, most Sondheim is even more specific. Maybe using the phrase "...the first to do it so specifically" wasn't the best choice, but what I was trying to say was that he wasn't the fisrt to write character specific numbers, he is just, in my opinion as well as many others, the best at it. Not to mention he works much harder than most everyone else, so as to make it so specific.

---

Unfortunately, I don't think any of the three-named composers will do much to bring the art form into the next century. As much as I repsect LaChuisa, Brown and Guettel (technically only two names, but you know what I mean), I don't they really could ever swim the waters of commercial theatre with any success. Or at least they haven't to date.

The Marc Shaimans of the world (along with the authors of AVE Q, URINETOWN and the lot) are wonderfully talented pastiche artists. But I doubt their works will last through time, either.

Aside from the old guard (Schwartz, Sondheim, Schonberg), the only new-ish writers out there at the moment who writes original yet accessible material are William Finn and the team of Ahrens and Flaherty. I don't know that A&F (not to be confused with the catalog) have really influenced a lot of writers, but I think a case could be made for Finn. He inspired a lot of idiosyncratic, quirky souls to put their works out there. Ya gotta love that!

TT

---