It was a great reopening night! The energy from the audience was electric, and all of the celebrations were beautiful, emotional, and impactful. All of the events that went down have already been explained so well, I’ll only give my opinion of the show itself.
I think the show is overall in really good shape after all these years. The cast did feel a bit off at first, but found their footing relatively quickly, and there were some standouts particularly from Jessica Phillips, Gabrielle Carubba, and Ivan Hernandez (this was my first time seeing the show with this cast). The emotional impact of the show still hits where it needs to, and the production still feels tight. However…
Jordan Fisher’s performance did leave me cold at times. While his performance did improve in the second act, I found it it to be inconsistent and never reaching the same emotional heights as some previous Evans. I never really bought into him being an outsider or having anxiety. He constantly seemed in control of himself and the situation, which made me begin to feel some of the criticisms people have had of the show itself. I was not on his side.
He had some very strong moments, especially with a lot of the comedy, and Words Fail and his final monologue were standouts. I appreciated the nuance and different take on the character there, but it just felt that the emotional payoff wasn’t as strong because of some of his Act 1 choices. Act 2 didn’t match what was set up before, and this was jarring. He was overall fine, and the show is definitely still worth seeing, but yeah, he is the weakest Evan I’ve seen so far.