As someone mentioned, that revival and CZJ have their fans, but there are just as many who did not care for any of it. I saw the production at the Menier and found it to be a missed opportunity, albeit with two fantastic central performances in Hannah Waddingham as Desiree and Maureen Lipman as Mme. Armfeldt. On paper, the Broadway company seemed perfect and I figured in that year since Menier, Nunn might have learned from his mistakes. But when I went to see the Broadway production two months into the run, I was even more disappointed than I was in London.
I found CZJ stunningly beautiful, but lacking any warmth or grace or real connection with anyone on stage. I found Lansbury to also be completely in the wrong direction. Her Mme. Armfeldt, to me, acted like a traditional, cooky, but ultimately loving grandmother, which I've never found the character to be. And the entire supporting company, while mostly well-sung all seemed as if they were in different shows, and none of those shows were Night Music.
I went back in July to see Bernadette Peters and Elaine Stritch during their second week of performances, mostly because I knew that if I didn't, I would never see Stritch live in anything. While Stritch was known to drop lines and miss entire verses, she was letter perfect on the text the night I saw her and she and Peters were beyond exceptional. The entire company, in fact, while not 100% there, had all shifted their performances in the right direction, which I think came more from that Nunn had left the company and they all slowly removed themselves from his drab vision.
I went back and found my old review of the show, ending with this line: "What this production needs is Michael Blakemore's comedic timing, Bartlett Sher's style and NONE of Trevor Nunn's 'elegance.'" I still agree with it.
"Sing the words, Patti!!!!" Stephen Sondheim to Patti LuPone.
Updated On: 6/1/16 at 02:22 PM