There ought to be a book on the pre-Broadway Funny Girl dish.
It opened in Boston and bombed. Kanin didn't have a clue and Robbins came in then. Kanin was unseen for the rest of the tryout. He did get his royalties however. Within the biz, it is thought of as a Robbins show. 5 songs were replaced and 50Gs worth of scenery out of a then-record 750Gs total budget (Dolly and Fiddler each came in for 375G) was tossed out.
Cut songs: on Barbra's "People" album, Absent Minded Me is one of the cut songs (maybe for Who Are You Now?) and supposedly Roller Skate Rag that used in the film was cut either in rehearsal or out of town and was replaced by Cornet Man. (The skates survived however--look at the logo; the upside down girl is wearing skates.)
You Are Woman was originally done straight, and it is said that it was Barbra's idea to make it farcical and that worked but good.
After Boston was 3 weeks in Philly where they were still in trouble. The NY opening was delayed, and they extended 2 weeks in Philly. However the Forrest where they were playing had another booking so they switched theatres to the since-demolished and little used Erlanger. This is the only instance of a show trying out switching theatres in the same city that I know of.
Then in a time when shows were only starting to play public previews in NY, Funny Girl had about 3 weeks of them. By comparison that season Dolly and others had none.
There were seven different announced opening nights including 3 in the final week: first was Tuesday the 24th, then Sunday the 22nd and finally Thursday March 26th. The show opened 4 weeks later than originally announced.
The last scene had about 45 versions, the last of which was being rehearsed by Barbra and Sydney Chaplin behind the house curtain as the audience was entering the theatre on opening night.
The book (and film script for that matter) is strictly by the numbers: good girl with talent held back but not for long, by a no-good man who did her wrong. The score on the other hand is one of the all-time greats.
I read the NY Times faithfully during this stormy tryout and pieced a lot of this together from that. There were also major cover articles in Time, Life and Look Magazines that made mention of the various trials and tribulations. Add in later info from vaious books and yet the whole story does not appear in any one place.
Barbra ended up on stage for all but 20 minutes of the show which basically covered her 4 hair style changes (in these pre-wig days) and 10-12 costume changes.
And to think this was first offered to Mary Martin (at age 50 no less) and then to Anne Bancroft!
PS - Yes, she and Chaplin had a fling out-of-town. When they came back to NY they went home to their respective spouses. However something was not right and 8 months after opening Chaplin was let go and bought out of his contract. It took a while before another "name" was engaged to play Nick. He was Johnny Desmond who was a nightclub singer and a wholly instinctive actor. A stage manager blocked him into the show, but Barbra came in afterwards and directed him into it. Johnny played the rest of the run with Barbra who he got along with fine and later with Mimi Hines with whom he decidedly did not.
The Johnny-info came from the woman who was living with Johnny at the time. Never mind that Johnny had a wife living elsewhere and to whom he returned.
"If my life weren't funny, it would just be true. And that would be unacceptable."
--Carrie Fisher