QueenAlice said: "The roster of mega hit Broadway musicals is absolutely littered with what, on paper, are horrendous ideas. A musical about Orphan Annie? A musical about dancing Cats? A musical about an obscure South American dictator's wife? A hip hop musical about Alexander Hamilton and the list goes on and on..
An idea unto itself doesn't mean much. It's what the authors and creatives do with the idea that counts. Anything is possible."
True, but the fact that this has been in the works for 6 years without much apparent forward momentum doesn’t inspire optimism. Unless this is done very camp, I can’t see this working at all. I know there are no bad ideas; just bad execution. I was an early naysayer of Spongebob, but had a splendid time when I saw it last month. I still predict Green Acres will be a commercial flop if it ever makes it to Broadway. If Spongebob, which had a somewhat built-in demographic as its desired audience, couldn’t succeed, I don’t know who the demographic for this would even be. If it does materialize, I would suggest it might fare better off-Broadway, but only with if they go in a camp direction. After all, most of the shows you mention had respected source materials: a vibrant comic strip, a book of poems by T.S. Eliot, a lauded tome of non-fiction. And they all had a crackerjack creative team (even Cats which I despise). Obviously, just my opinion.
Updated On: 7/12/18 at 01:11 PM