Let's think of some performances that would be great, definitive even, if they happened or were to happen, but will absolutely never take place. This can be because the actor is dead, the show is never revived, or the actor in question would never take such a role.
Imagine this- maybe on stage, maybe as a studio recording, but the late Freddie Mercury as Jean Valjean in Les Miserables. It would have been phenomenal.
Darren Criss as Andrew Jackson in BLOODY BLOODY ANDREW JACKSON.
Ethel Merman as Christine in Phantom?
Stand-by Joined: 10/8/10
Ethel Merman as Usnavi in IN The Heights
^ I saw Ethel as Usnavi and she was fantastic, not as good as her Elphaba though.
"Curtain UPPPPPP! Light The Lights Up In Washington Heights"
You guys joke, but Merman's Blanche DuBois was one of the most thrilling experiences of my entire life.
Vincent Price as The Narrator/Mysterious Man in INTO THE WOODS
"Darren Criss as Andrew Jackson in BLOODY BLOODY ANDREW JACKSON."
I think that falls under the category of Horrible Performances We'll Never, Ever See...
Ditto to the Vincent Price thing, and let me also add that he would have been PHENOMENAL as The Narrator in a production/remake of Rocky Horror.
Patti LuPone as Diana in n2n. i think it would be AMAZING.
Nick Adams in NAKED BOYS SINGING
Rosie O'Donnell as Effie in Dreamgirls
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/10/08
I hope to God Bernadette Peters in Sweeney Todd doesn't fall into this category.
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/15/03
Loretta Swit in GYPSY.
I hold to my theory that Mary Louise Parker would be a great Diana.
More ones that are unlikely for one reason or another-
Gerard Way as Roger 'Pink' Pinkerton in THE WALL (he'd never take a full-time acting role, and I doubt that Roger Waters is ever actually going to finish adapting the show)
Michael Jackson as Dr. Frank-N-Furter (imagine a Frank that can be strange and campy WITHOUT simply channeling 1940s grande dames)
David Bowie as Sweeney Todd- I know I've just mentioned 3 pop singers, but Bowie is as respected an actor than as a singer (more so since he stopped working on new music), and just IMAGINE that famous voice speaking and singing Sweeney's iconic lines.
Reba in Whorehouse
Reba in Anything Goes
Caroline O'Connor in Evita
Nathan Lane in The Boy From Oz
I love the idea of Bowie as Sweeney! I would run to see that. Maybe with Cyndi Lauper as Lovett? :)
Nathan Lane as Zero Mostel in ZERO HOUR.
A young Mark Hamill as Finch in How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying.
Don Knotts as The Wizard in Wicked.
Britney Spears in Sweet Charity.
It's not that it can't happen, but I'm curious as to how she would do in the role as well as how critics would view her.
Swing Joined: 12/22/10
Jackie Gleason as Pseudolus (Martin Gottfried wrote Forum was announced for him) or as the star of Saul Bellow's The Last Analysis.
Natasha Richardson as Desiree in a fully-staged production of A Little Night Music.
Videos